First, congratulations on your successful quit! That is a real accomplishment.
Juice flavors are so subjective, but the first juice I could actually really taste after trying the tobacco ones with no success, is Cinnamon Roll from Mt. Baker Vapor, their standard blend, 80pg/20vg, with no flavor shots. It is still one of my very favorites after a couple of months. I keep a tank filled with it, and vape it at least every day in my rotation.
I can also recommend the MBV mixed berry flavor called Get Razzled. It has a nice kick to it, and isn't too sweet.
If you haven't ordered from them before, I highly recommend them for good, inexpensive juice and great service and shipping. If you order at least $15 worth, you get a free 15 ml sample of your choice. Just specify what you want in the comment section when you check out.
They have a thing where you can order extra flavor shots, but I've always just ordered as is. Some people say they must "steep" the juice, but I personally have liked it really well right out of the mail. But, like I said, taste is subjective.
I'd say it might be worth it to order $15 worth and get a free sample, too, and see what you think.
PS I just got a new order from them today, and my free sample is Extreme Ice. If you like a really cool tasting menthol I would recommend it, too.
One more - I've also reordered the Butterscotch and like it a lot.