Help with switches!!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

dmohn28

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 1, 2009
72
0
Iowa, USA
Several weeks ago, I put together a 6v nicostick using a ti ptn04050 booster chip. Since then, I have gone through about 6 different switches.

I have tried the cheap n/o momentary switches, tactile switches, and now I'm trying spst push on - off type. I actually prefer the non momentary switches, but I can't keep one going for my life. I am averaging 3 to 4 days on these switches right now.

I have been using exclusively Radioshack switches, and I suspect that might be the problem, but I don't know.
 

Nuck

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
2,265
10
Ontario, Canada
Several weeks ago, I put together a 6v nicostick using a ti ptn04050 booster chip. Since then, I have gone through about 6 different switches.

I have tried the cheap n/o momentary switches, tactile switches, and now I'm trying spst push on - off type. I actually prefer the non momentary switches, but I can't keep one going for my life. I am averaging 3 to 4 days on these switches right now.

I have been using exclusively Radioshack switches, and I suspect that might be the problem, but I don't know.

Unless the switch is rated for a minimum of 2amps you should add a mosfet to the circuit. It will stop the switch carnage :)
 

MastiffMike

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 9, 2009
5,744
7,751
Dogville Estate
I was just at RS yesterday and picked up a few things. I noticed these switches (275-1571 & 275-1547) are both .5 Amp. Switches 275-644 and 275-1555 are 3 Amp.

madvapes (and other places) have switches from <.5 Amp to >6 Amp. It seems though that the switch has to get bigger as the Amps go up :(

I did notice that some of the switches at MVs are rated 2 or 3 amp and the same size as the
.5 Amp RS switches. So just look around and avoid the <2 Amp ones!

I have some .5 Amp switches I LOVE but am afraid to use b/c of longevity issues but I do have a sweet 6 Amp dual-rocker switch I'm gonna use soon!
 
Last edited:

MastiffMike

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 9, 2009
5,744
7,751
Dogville Estate
The rocker is Awesome! It's a dual and one is momentary (for vaping) and the other isn't (for master on/off). I wish it was a hair smaller in size though. The feel of it is very nice (though a tad firmer than my normal push-buttons), and a nice click to the on/off.

The rocker I have is the RS-127 here:
DUAL ROCKER SWITCH, SPST & SPDT MOMENTARY | AllElectronics.com

RockerSwitch.jpg


Note: Item in picture is actually smaller than it appears in the picture!

Back to the OP question - Madvapes LDO 5v regulator allows you to use any switch you want w/o worrying about it burning up since it has a control pin!
 

Ralph Hilton

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 2, 2009
121
1
Semmering, Austria
Here's an automatic mod. I tried with a pressure switch but it was too fiddly so this uses a small mouth activated touch switch.
IMG_7316.jpg

Its built on easily available 0.1" stripboard.
IMG_7302.jpg

The components are quite small so I've added wires to them first. The op amp is on the left and the mosfet is the smaller chip on the right.
IMG_7303.jpg

A soldering iron with a fine tip is needed.
IMG_7304.jpg

And a magnifier is almost essential.
IMG_7305.jpg

A third hand holds the op amp for connecting wires to it.
IMG_7306.jpg

Then the amp is wired on the board.
IMG_7307.jpg

And the mosfet above it.
IMG_7308.jpg

Then the resistors are added.
IMG_7309.jpg

A cut in the board is needed on the other side.
IMG_7310.jpg

Next the connecting wires red +ve black -ve blue to atty and yellow to the sensor.
IMG_7311.jpg

IMG_7312.jpg

If that seems a bit too fiddly here is an earlier version with larger components in a bigger box.
IMG_7313.jpg

Here's the first one I made earlier in a tin case. I put the circuit board in hot glue for protection.
For easier wiring the case is positive and acts as a return for the sensor.
IMG_7314.jpg

The sensor itself is just a small piece of brass rod.
IMG_7315.jpg
 

Nuck

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
2,265
10
Ontario, Canada
I build and use 5V nic sticks. Love them, hate RS switches.

I have bee using this little push button and they have been holding up well.

Here is a link

Jameco Electronics Electromechanical: MOUNTAIN SWITCH: MS-402-RED


Those are rated for 0.5amp. At 5v you are pulling over 2.2 amps with a 510.

There are a ton of cheap n-channel mosfets that will protect the switch and allow modders to use pretty much any switch and will extend the life of the switch to it it's max potential.

There are small and easy to use. The switch will pull almost no current (micro amps) when using a mosfet.
 

Nuck

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
2,265
10
Ontario, Canada

DVS

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 8, 2009
90
0
Hawaii
Those are rated for 0.5amp. At 5v you are pulling over 2.2 amps with a 510.

There are a ton of cheap n-channel mosfets that will protect the switch and allow modders to use pretty much any switch and will extend the life of the switch to it it's max potential.

There are small and easy to use. The switch will pull almost no current (micro amps) when using a mosfet.

Those switches are rated for 125 volts, as are RS. So at 5 volts that .5amp @ 125 volts switch is plenty enough.
 

Nuck

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 14, 2009
2,265
10
Ontario, Canada
Those switches are rated for 125 volts, as are RS. So at 5 volts that .5amp @ 125 volts switch is plenty enough.

It doesn't work that way. The DC supply would reduce the maximum voltage to around 30v (its not specified on the datasheet) but even then you can't count on it. Exceeding either the voltage OR the current seems to reduce the life dramatically. I'm not sure why but based on experience it definitely does.
 

FizzleFisch

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 20, 2009
182
5
Lake Travis - Texas
I've used a few different types. My last order I grabbed these:

Digi-Key - IRLU3114ZPBF-ND (Manufacturer - IRLU3114ZPBF)

They are small but still large enough that my old man eyes don't bleed.


Hey thanks for that! - Yeah they're pretty small at alright (<7mm sq.)...
...but I think I can still work with 'em too. -- Just about right though for those small 2XAAA or 1XA batt-boxes.

Rds & Id specs are also way better than what I had scrounged up from a couple of old parts drawers here.

Boy...can I ever relate to the "old-man eyes" reference. :(

Again thanks!:thumb:

fisch
 

dmohn28

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 1, 2009
72
0
Iowa, USA
Those are rated for 0.5amp. At 5v you are pulling over 2.2 amps with a 510.

There are a ton of cheap n-channel mosfets that will protect the switch and allow modders to use pretty much any switch and will extend the life of the switch to it it's max potential.

There are small and easy to use. The switch will pull almost no current (micro amps) when using a mosfet.


So I've never used a mosfet. Just to be sure.... I would wire from power source -> mosfet -> switch-> atty. Is that right? AND, does the mosfet have any effect on the voltage?

I currently run 6.2 volts using two 14500's in parallel with a TI ptn04050 booster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread