I'm looking for a juice to replicate my former analog of choice (Camel Menthol)

[ErrantVandal]

In particular I'm looking for that "You're freebasing a Halls" sort of menthol and throat hit from a Camel Menthol Full Flavor with the bead crushed (yes I'm that guy who likes Menthol^2)


Any suggestions?

 

[Maximillian]

Heyas ErrantVandal,

You might try http://www.johnsoncreeksmokejuice.com/product/J025?r=rightnav

I haven't tried that particular one, but I've sampled another johnson creek mentol and liked it.


Happy Hunting,
Maximillian the Moderately Mischievious

 

[washvap]

WELCOME TO THE ECF

My favorite menthol/tobacco flavor is Newport Beach from Titan Vapors. It's a REAL strong menthol with some robust tobacco in the background.

Titan Vapors

 

[Maximillian]

Or possibly, Original Smoke Juice - Arctic Menthol™

Didn't notice that the first one was pg-free

Maximillian the Vaguely Disreputable

 

[frosting]

Welcome to ECF, glad you found us and are on your journey to say goodbye to ciggies!

I have to recommend Mr E's Menthol. Mister E's Menthol - Mister-E-Liquid.com In the full version it is a knock you on your bottom icy hit. I have smoked camel crush menthol and think you might like that. Very to menthol flavor at least it seemed like that to me and I smoked menthol for a long time.

I also must suggest you please be open to more flavors! You may find you enjoy something fruity, sweet, even more then menthol/tobacco. Mr. E also has some amazing menthol combo flavors. My favorite has to be Grape Ice.

 

[osirisorion]

I was an avid camel menthol / crush smoker, loved
Those poppable menthol beads you might wanna try
Gotvapes menthol it's pretty close I think! the other thing
That's nice is you can add 2-3 drops of that to any other juice and have a frosty flavorful menthol juice!

 

[Ridgerunner]

I have found Johnson Creek smoke juice to have some good menthol flavors and they are US made.

 

[CaminoDiablo]

Just an idea, get some menthol crystals from perfumers apprentice and add all you want to your fav juice. Costs $12 for 4ozs. Perfumers Apprentice - Menthol Crystals

 

[brittanyNI]

If you are into DIY, for a tobacco menthol of this sort I'd recommend ... (for 6ml of juice) ...

4 drops Seedman's Virginia Fire-Cured
2 drops Flavour Art Shade
1 drop The Flavor Apprentice DK Tobacco Base

these give the tobacco flavor

2 drops The Flavor Apprentice Creme De Menth
1 drops The Flavor Apprentice Wintergreen
6 drops The Flavor Apprentice Menthol liquid (PG based)

these give the menthol

3 drops of Apple flavor -- many are good for this, it adds interest
1 drop Flavour Art MTS Vape Whiz -- mellows out the rough edges

With this sort of flavor I use about 50% PG, 45% Glycerin and 5% 100 proof vodka, with the nicotine as part of the PG.

 

[emanguba]

From what I've read, try Volcano's Menthol Burst.

One of the reviewers noted exactly what you are looking for: "i would say it def. tastes like a camel menthol cig with that ball they now have in the filters snapped open. really has that extra burst of menthol. i've always been a menthol smoker but with this one i like to tweak the taste a little. i like to add the vanilla bean to it. makes it a little smoother but still has that freshness to it "

 

[ErrantVandal]

Thanks guys.

Welcome to ECF, glad you found us and are on your journey to say goodbye to ciggies!

I have to recommend Mr E's Menthol. Mister E's Menthol - Mister-E-Liquid.com In the full version it is a knock you on your bottom icy hit. I have smoked camel crush menthol and think you might like that. Very to menthol flavor at least it seemed like that to me and I smoked menthol for a long time.

I also must suggest you please be open to more flavors! You may find you enjoy something fruity, sweet, even more then menthol/tobacco. Mr. E also has some amazing menthol combo flavors. My favorite has to be Grape Ice.

I have tried a bunch actually. My current fave non-menthol is Totally Wicked's Parma Violet. I bought a bunch of their e-liquids and I'll post a review in the e-liquid review forums when my post count is high enough.

 

[Aunt Cranky]

Halo menthol ice is pretty strong stuff, so strong that you want to devote a dedicated atty to the stuff

Halo makes good quality juice, decent prices, and they have a few menthol flavors to choose from.