It does depends on how many analogs you were using moreso than whether they were lights or not. How fast an analog burns depends on how much extra junk they add to them so the faster they burn, the more 'you' would have smoked, depending how long you could go in between before having an all out nicotine fit.
I smoked every brand under the sun, moon, rain, snow, etc. & was at slightly over 2 pks/day chain smoking.
You're going to want to try all the menthol flavs to be sure but there's a general agreement most of us around have reached - NOTHING is a good as SMILIN SPECIAL MENTHOL.
I started at 18 - not enough. 24 - still not enough. 36 hits the spot for me but I still can't stop the frequency of vaping w/ only menthol. I also vape WOW Peppermint @24mg (love the Classic Caramel Mocha Frapp @ 24 but think that one has to go- anything too-too close to real food tastes and I get suspended in a vaping altitude zone I don't like - the CCMF is also very thick so it makes me go through more blanks than any other flav I've tried as an all day vape) WowBoy to me is great - sort of minty, pronounced chocolate with a hint of tobacco for when I feel like I'm going to cave and a lighter juice than CCMF. Some of what you experience depends on your carto choice and if you vape on a battery or PT - all but the menthol changes slightly in flavor and/or vapor production based on how you vape it. This is why imo, the opposite it true about menthol analog 'quitters' - It's easier to tell where you're at because for some reason, menthol is a familiar taste. It made quitting easier for me. The other flavs + an 8mg strawberry at night, which is totally relaxing (in a coolcart) makes my all day vape less. I can probably go through 3 carts/day but I can't get through 1 full menthol cart even I vape nothing else BECAUSE it's so strong - If I don't put it down, I might feel a little sick. iow, with all flavs and mgs considered I'm far from vaping 36/day and closer to 22, still less than (and none of the junk in) analogs.
You'll find your comfort and figure out what to do from there. Until then, just enjoy the journey.
And pianoguy, don't say 'can't' cause I don't fight w/ ya or anyone else but you advised snus on a vaping help forum. I don't care what anyone says - every ad in and out of stores for it, says it causes mouth cancer - no mights or maybes like on packs of analogs - flat out "This product is known to cause mouth cancer". This isn't Sweden or a snus group. (I'm so sick of this conversatiion) If people told you can't it would be harder so don't say what you and everyone else doesn't and won't know until RWG goes through all the menthol testers to believe it. (Nuport is not bad but not close to SMILIN SPECIAL)
Vaping is a safest choice you could make. Big deal if you like menthol - makes it easier to switch to a chewing gum to try a quit gum, which is an alternative to a safe vaping product. You won't need to though if you keep giving yourself a chance.
Put tobacco road/alley/gutter behind you because you'll quit with V4L and everyone here's help, including pianoguy when he's not getting off topic. Don't give up and you'll do it in a day or a month but you will never want to touch another analog again.
Welcome aboard!
