I think we all are a bit frustrated with finding a flavor that we love when we first start
vaping. Trial and error seem to be the way most of us take. Unfortunately, nothing is going to be even close to a brand of cigarettes flavor, however, you
can find good enough!
I find that VaporTalk Mentha is a great flavor of menthol (strong) and I've seen posts with others who smoked Misty who have used this (but didn't think it was identical to Misty, just good). You can always mix a good
tobacco flavor with it.
If you don't get the menthol hit you want, you can always make your own menthol drops (to add to almost any flavor!) with menthol crystals and PGA (EverClear Alcohol). This is a great set of directions and helpful information:
http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/diy-e-liquid/20590-menthol-drops-recipe-menthol-lovers.html
Menthol crystals can be purchased inexpensively on eBay. I bought mine from Gumby96.
MENTHOL CRYSTALS 2 Ounces oz Mentha arvensis 100% pure - eBay (item 200449270862 end time Apr-11-10 01:29:16 PDT) You don't need much so don't buy a huge wad of it, you'll never use it all then. I bought 2 oz. and have barely scratched the bunch.
The drops come in handy to add strong menthol kick and throat hit to wimpy or bad tasting menthol juice.