I started vaping again a few months back and have had lots of different juices since I first tried it unsuccessfully in 2009. Like others have said, very few that I actually have liked or would be able to completely quit analogs.
The first all day juice I found with the help of this great place was called Gandalf from heathers heavenly vapes. It actually helped me almost quit analogs, was down to 4 to 6 analogs a day using this @ 24mg nic. here is a link
Gandalf (Purity) - $5.00 : Heathers Heavenly Vapes, Top Quality Custom E-Liquids
Then I discovered the new WTA lines from Aroma. Stands for Whole Tobacco Alkaloids. This was just last week and I have not had an analog since Thursday AM and only one. So I am 4 days without an analog which is a miracle since I smoked a pack and half a day for 26 years. Unreal.
The DK-TAB tastes the most like an analog to me and I love it. Here is a link.
Whole Tobacco Alkaloid WTA Eliquid Ejuice
He sent me a sample of Beetlejuice WTA and it is good also, kinda reminds me of a sugar cookie, roasted peanuts, kinda,, very subtle though not overpowering.
One more would be Wet Your Sticks cuban cigar, and tabacco. I like these but they are china juices, not homeade. Also they are a sweet tabaccoeeee taste. I don't think that is a word LOL.
Wet Your Stick E-Liquid
The last time I bought from Matt @ wet our stick was in 2009 so I had some leftover from when I last tried vaping. What I mean is we didn't have the VG/PG options and stuff so I don't know what blend to tell you I had.
Sorry for such a long post but I understand your frustration since I have just went through it just recently, I mean trying to find one that would satisfy me enough to quit analogs. The juice for that first thing in the morning satisfaction and after eating, having a evening drink and crave that analog. That juice was a combination of Gandalf as an all day vape and the DK-TAB infused with WTA for the morning, after eating, cold beer.
Good luck and I hope you have success. It can get overwhelming.
Dan