Hey Alyssa.... I'll give you my
I'm moderately new to this vaping world, and I honestly haven't tried too many different juices (although I have about 60+ bottles between my stashes at work and at home
) I've ordered from Mt. Baker Vapor a couple of times. Volcano ECigs was the first bottled juice I ever got (LONG story there....) Theirs is 70/30, with 0, 8, 16, or 24mg nic. No customizations; no flavor shots. It's o.k., but it's generally single-layer flavors. MBV you can customize, it's relatively inexpensive, and arrives within a few days from ordering. I'm pretty hung up on my local B&M (CravinVapes) who makes all their juice to order and even has a website for internet orders.
I frequently see references to Nicoticket, Halo, Ahlusions and Five Pawns. I've only tested Halo, but I did pick up a bottle of Five Pawns (only as a special treat because it's quite a bit more expensive than even my local juice.) Never tried either of the other two.
Besides, what you will like probably isn't what I'll like or vice versa. If you want to try different things, google ejuice sample packs. There are a number of vendors who offer smaller bottles in groups to allow you to sample their wares. Zamplebox.com is a subscription plan where you get a variety of juices each month for as little as $25/month. Supposedly up to 60 mL juice - that's in the ballpark of about $0.40-0.50/mL - not too terribly bad IMO.
If you're fairly new, try little bottles from a lot of different places (or better yet, if you have a B&M in your area, and they make their own, give them a whirl.)
You'll find things you like, and you may even find that what you like today, you won't be able to stand in a couple of months.....
Good luck