I think this may be a topic that would divide people, lol.
I believe it would be up to personal taste. But I have tried both, so I will give my honest opinion.
I prefer Perfumer's Apprentice and the reasons why are:
I think her flavors are true flavors, most of them taste exactly like I expected. But I do have issue with certain flavors not being strong enough, but most of them are fair to strong in flavor. I also like that she hasn't added any dyes or colorings to her flavors. Even though some of them have a bit of "tint" to them, I think it's more of the flavoring do it, then say Red 40. On top of that, Linda is a kick-... chick and her customer service is great!
Now for LorAnn's:
The biggest problem I have is dye. Seriously, a lot of them are rainbow colored, but that's just my preference for no dyes. I have enough allergies as it is. I also have a problem with a weird after taste and some of the flavors need a bit more "sweetening" than I really wanna do. But...there's a plus side. They've been in business for a long time, and they seems to be easy to find in certain areas in a brick & mortar store. And despite the dark purple color, I do love their grape flavor.
Hope this a more helpful than confusing
