Pick 10

[Kent Brooks]

tobacco
H1N1/The Virus*
Radioactive

BAKERY
CLS*
CB*
Frenilla
Peanut Butter Cookie
Butterscotch Pudding


FRUIT
Betelgeuse*
Gravity*
Grape Ape
Hummingbird

CINNAMON
GCD*
Doodle

HYBRIDS
Wakonda
Raz Cup
Banana Pudding



*Denotes non-negotiable by virtue of the fact that it won a Best of ECF 2013 Award.

 

[DaBucs]

peanut butter cookie?

oh wait you said when that comes back it was gonna be a pbj?

 

[Merbearw]

Virus.
10 char
edit: 'cause it's not the same as H1N1, or I may be soooo wrong

 

[VAscooter]

Qoh...........

 

[emily n portland]

Hummingbird
Raz Cup

 

[fraychek]

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
You don't need both GCD and Doodle or Gravity and Betelgeuse.

 

[gopher_byrd]

Peanut Butter Cookie!

 

[Kent Brooks]

peanut butter cookie?

oh wait you said when that comes back it was gonna be a pbj?

I'm thinking more "long term" here. I have several short-runs "promised." -- one is PB&J -- we'll leave that one off the list for now (until we can get more feedback - only a precious few have tasted it)

 

[Kent Brooks]

Qoh...........

Honestly - I love it too - but QoH isn't even under consideration for the final 10 -- we have two fruit slots (BG and Gravity) -- any other fruit will be a hybrid (Raz Cup, yet to be released Strawberry Custard)

 

[NicoleNXD]

H1N1/The Virus
CLS
CB
Frenilla
Betelgeuse
Gravity
GCD
Doodle
Butterscotch Pudding
Banana Pudding
Radioactive
Wakonda
Grape Ape
Peanut Butter Cookie

What's missing?

Frenilla
CB
CLS
Butterscotch Pudding
Banana Pudding
Gravity
Betelgeuse
H1N1/virus
GCD
Radioactive

 

[Kent Brooks]

Hummingbird
Raz Cup

Both legit contenders - added - see how hard this is going to be?

 

[DivideMyDestiny]

This thread makes me sad. Knowing that Nicoticket's cutting the roster down just is disheartening, but it must be done. Are you asking for missing flavors? Apricot Ambition, Be Mine, and Coolcumber Mint are missing.

Are you actually asking if it was our call to pick 10?

 

[Kent Brooks]

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
You don't need both GCD and Doodle or Gravity and Betelgeuse.

I can't cut GCD, Gravity, or Betelgeuse - they all garnered awards for the Best of ECF 2013... and... too many people have them as ADVs. Honestly, despite not being an award winner, Doodle is loved by so widely popular... it's going to be hard to cut.

 

[VAscooter]

PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
You don't need both GCD and Doodle or Gravity and Betelgeuse.

I agree on the BG and Gravity. For me they are both to similar. I'm probably in the minority though.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Tapatalk

 

[Kent Brooks]

My list would be the same.

The problem is, we're up to 16, so 6 of those may never been seen again!~

 

[NicoleNXD]

The problem is, we're up to 16, so 6 of those may never been seen again!~

I edited my post

 

[Mark Howard]

My 10, in order of importance:
1. Wakonda
2. PBC
3. CLS
4. CB
5. Frenilla
6. Radioactive
7. Virus
8. Betelguese
9. Gravity
10. GCD or Doodle (I don't care for either but they are beloved by fam enough to be on the list)

I could be fine with only Wakonda until the end of time. I sure hope I can order enough to make it my ADV and never have to go without it again. Down to my last 2oz of it, and no other juice with me. Don't get home til Tuesday night so I'm going to have to find some crappy juice in Minneapolis to get me through.

 

[VAscooter]

The problem is Clark that everyone has different tastes and favorites. I'm at the point on the fruits that I like a creamier tasting fruit which is why I'm mixing either cls or Frenilla with my gravity and BG. Hard decision for you but no dogs IMHO in NT.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N900A using Tapatalk

 

[Kent Brooks]

This thread makes me sad. Knowing that Nicoticket's cutting the roster down just is disheartening, but it must be done. Are you asking for missing flavors? Apricot Ambition, Be Mine, and Coolcumber Mint are missing.

Are you actually asking if it was our call to pick 10?

As of now, Coolcumber Mint isn't really an option - not enough feedback but that's subject to change. Honestly, unless feedback is overwhelming, this might be the first and the last run of it. We'll see how the Hit it or Quit it thread stacks up.

Apricot Ambition, while I really really love the flavor - probably won't see the light of day again.

Be Mine is delicious - but it's a super deep steep (the Dragon Fruit is obnoxious fresh)... probably not a consideration for the final 10, we'd have to hold inordinate ammts of stock just to field it.


Sorry, I should clarify... ultimately the final decision will be ours, but we want/need feedback. Under the assumption that you could only pick 10 flavors out of the flavors in the OP - which 10 would they be? Also, some justification or logic for the choices would be good. We're - kicking things around.

 

[DivideMyDestiny]

Kent,
Could you put asterisks by the liquids on the top post that are absolutely 100% non-negotiable? I think it would help me to provide feedback at least on what I'd like to see.