SKYYcamel Ultra Member ECF Veteran Verified Member Apr 15, 2009 2,170 3,097 Mississippi Mar 16, 2011 #1 Mar 16, 2011 Add bookmark #1 I was just wondering how the Flavor Apprentice RY4 compared to Dekang RY4. Thanks! ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
R RenaissancePuffer Unregistered Supplier ECF Veteran Jul 10, 2009 967 43 New Germany, MN www.OneStopDIYShop.com Mar 16, 2011 #2 Mar 16, 2011 Add bookmark #2 It needs some caramel and sweetener in my opinion, but it has some similar tastes to RY4. ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
ByStander1 Super Member ECF Veteran Feb 3, 2011 514 283 West Virginia Apr 3, 2011 #3 Apr 3, 2011 Add bookmark #3 RenaissancePuffer said: It needs some caramel and sweetener in my opinion, but it has some similar tastes to RY4. Click to expand... Absolutely on the Caramel. From there, mine didn't need any sweetener though. Delicious!!! ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
RenaissancePuffer said: It needs some caramel and sweetener in my opinion, but it has some similar tastes to RY4. Click to expand... Absolutely on the Caramel. From there, mine didn't need any sweetener though. Delicious!!!
keelalagirl55 ECF Guru ECF Veteran Jan 25, 2011 30,547 74,837 Apr 7, 2011 #4 Apr 7, 2011 Add bookmark #4 What percentage caramel are you adding to it? I found it kinda bland too, but didn't wanna over do the caramel. ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
What percentage caramel are you adding to it? I found it kinda bland too, but didn't wanna over do the caramel.
ByStander1 Super Member ECF Veteran Feb 3, 2011 514 283 West Virginia Apr 9, 2011 #5 Apr 9, 2011 Add bookmark #5 keelalagirl55 said: What percentage caramel are you adding to it? I found it kinda bland too, but didn't wanna over do the caramel. Click to expand... I added 10% caramel to mine. I like strong flavors. Hope it helps! ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
keelalagirl55 said: What percentage caramel are you adding to it? I found it kinda bland too, but didn't wanna over do the caramel. Click to expand... I added 10% caramel to mine. I like strong flavors. Hope it helps!
keelalagirl55 ECF Guru ECF Veteran Jan 25, 2011 30,547 74,837 Apr 9, 2011 #6 Apr 9, 2011 Add bookmark #6 ByStander1 said: I added 10% caramel to mine. I like strong flavors. Hope it helps! Click to expand... Yes...thank you! I like mine strong too ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
ByStander1 said: I added 10% caramel to mine. I like strong flavors. Hope it helps! Click to expand... Yes...thank you! I like mine strong too
robosax Full Member ECF Veteran Aug 21, 2009 29 1 ronkonkoma, NY robosax.com Apr 21, 2011 #7 Apr 21, 2011 Add bookmark #7 RenaissancePuffer said: It needs some caramel and sweetener in my opinion, but it has some similar tastes to RY4. Click to expand... thanks for that! I tried it and it really came alive with a drop of TFA Original Caramel Another RY4-ish flavor, imo, is TFA tobacco(Alc.). If you like smooth tobaccos, Flavor Art Royal, though not RY4-ish, is nice and light. robosax Last edited: Apr 21, 2011 ••• More options Report Add bookmark Share
RenaissancePuffer said: It needs some caramel and sweetener in my opinion, but it has some similar tastes to RY4. Click to expand... thanks for that! I tried it and it really came alive with a drop of TFA Original Caramel Another RY4-ish flavor, imo, is TFA tobacco(Alc.). If you like smooth tobaccos, Flavor Art Royal, though not RY4-ish, is nice and light. robosax