Hi Lori,
Not sure if I can be of much help. I regularly order
tobacco based Menthols from VR.
I'm currently - as in right this minute -
vaping Re(4)Nu Menthol and it's the only RY4 I've ever tried. The flavor is a cross between rich maple and caramel without being too sweet with a subtle undercurrent of a mild tobacco, if that makes
sense. (5 drops of this in 10 drops of VR Clove is my kinda vape...but I'm sure it wouldn't be for everyone).
I've only tried the tobaccos with menthol and my current favorite is the Smoke-Havana 2BackO Menthol (Premium Blend). I let it steep for a week but it was worth the wait - complicated, tobacco-y, floral-y, cigar-y, sprightly flavor. I'm in
love with this stuff. I also regularly stock in the East Coast Menthol, which can best be described as a dry, simple tobacco - nothing special or horrid - because it goes well with the Clove or Clove Menthol.
I always order double flavoring, 60/40 (PG/VG), 24 mg, Agressive throat hit. VaporRenu is my go-to for juice - can't beat the price, the ability to customize or all the different offerings. They're reasonable enough to try without risking a big loss if you don't like it. The only flavor I'm on the fence about from them is the Watermelon Mint because it's just one of those kinda flavors you either love or hate and not because they made it horrible. Imagine a candy watermelon flavor mixed with mint and you get the picture. Its...interesting.
Hope this helps a little.