At this point, I've tried quite a few and haven't even gotten the ones I'm trying by email. Heh. Well, hopefully they'll be good, but so far after running to all the vape stores within my driving range. (All 3 of them, but what can I say, I'm no longer in the big city.) My big thing is non-sweet. I smoke latakia heavy tobaccos in a pipe, love a good single malt, and adore ultra dark chocolate, even unsweetened if it's high enough quality.
But, well, the first store I went to only had EC and I was pretty unimpressed. I did find a 'non-sweet' fire and ice acceptable. Once I remembered to actually inhale, gave a really solid throat kick. That was more like it, but nothing to really write home about. It did do the job though of taking the place of the feel of analogs pretty well.
Then I tripped over Namber juice. Oh, if you like English and European tobaccos, nummy. I was having a blast playing, "Name that cigarette."
Many of their flavors actually taste like various high end cigs. Although one reminded me VERY strongly of Lucky Strikes, right down to the toasty notes on top.
Here's the gotcha though, they didn't push the 'This feels like a smoke' button. The fire and ice did. Hmmmm. I'm thinking that the cinnamon, menthol, clove bite might actually do the trick for people who have a hard time converting over to vaping. Might want to try it .
It's also a way to enjoy clove/menthol without ripping your lungs apart. I find this a plus, since I like those flavors, but in analogs they're even more deadly than tobacco. Especially clove. I'm thinking that's going to be my next lower end juice, just because I do like clove analogs, but never got into smoking them because they're so unhealthy.
tl;dr ejuice with a lot of cinnamon/clove/menthol gives a more analog like feel.