Ahh the illustrious search for pipe & cigar tobacco vape, or any tobacco vape. Actually, I've come real close to a cigar, pipe, and cigarette tasting vapes. All of them used Cappuccino as the main flavor. Cappuccino and Vanilla Bourbon gives a cigar/pipe like vape, Cappuccino and Cinnamon Danish, give a real thick pipe like vape, and Virginia Fired with a dash of Cinnamon Danish, and a tad bit of apple, gives a Cavendish like vape. I DIY juice, and have come up with some incredibly close tobacco like vapes on accident. Even one that tasted like a camel straight. But, since I've been vaping a little over 6 months, have found I don't much like these taste anymore. lol. But I did keep the Virginia Fired recipe, may make it again, it delivered a heavy thick vape, that was quite tasty.