IMR is a safer chemistry than Li-ion if something should go wrong they will just vent. Both AW types will work and are a good choice.
I'd recommend IMR if you're looking at the smaller
batteries like 14500 as they have a higher discharge rate. If you're in the 18650 range the discharge rate is high enough for Li-ion that they aren't really needed.
Edit: Just read you'll be using them in the P18. Go with Li-ion in that size as you'll get longer run times in between charges.