I would not have caved on the black star in your avatar my dude, I respect freedom of religion and freedom FROM religion. But having said that, if that's what's eating you, please don't let it. Either put the star back up or let it go. I would be offended if someone put a cross as their avatar, but it would be 'acceptable' by most, and I know they wouldn't change it b/c it offends me, and that's arrogance in spades. You kept the peace, I respect that.