A Review on Reviews

Status
Not open for further replies.

nerve007

Full Member
Dec 21, 2010
45
9
Canada
Since this is my first post, and I'm quite sure it won't generate much traffic, I'll start off with an attempt at making enemies... (not that I like to be the antagonist, but my opinions rarely coincide with those of others.)

Here we go:


As a seasoned vaper, I have spent much time browsing around ECF, youtube, and many other less traveled roads on the internet trying to find the perfect vape. I'm sure most of us have, especially when we are just entering the world of vaping.

When I became intrigued by the thought of getting my fix via vapour, I immediately turned to reviews to ensure the whole thing wasn't just a fad. That was about two years ago. Before the e-Go, before the mod revolution, but just as the community was taking off. After nights of research and a few weeks of waiting, my first 510 arrived at my doorstep. Within a day, I tossed half a pack of cigarettes in the trash and my lungs declared their freedom from the tyranny of tobacco.

I've kept fairly current on the latest mainstream (Joye) products since. I've even dabbled in mods once or twice. I'm the proud owner of the Ali'i, and I take my vaping very seriously. When I hear about a different device hitting the market, I have to research it. First thing I do is enjoy some video reviews. One is never enough though; I always need that second or eighth opinion before I'll consider dropping some Canadian coin.

Lately, I have discovered that my education and possible OCD are preventing me from enjoying the majority of reviews coming from the vaping community. Or perhaps there are just very few reviewers out there that know how to make an intelligent review... So here's where you're all going to love me or hate me:

1. Poorly Prepared and Impromptu Reviews
Ok, great. You got yourself a new e-cig and you just have to show it off to all these people you have never met, so you flip on the web cam with no regard for lighting, focus, noise, or your own personal appearance and hygiene (Yes, I can smell your breath all the way from Canada) and you stutter, mumble, and ummm your way through 8 minutes of my time, repeating cliches and catch phrases ad nauseam before you've even made up your own mind about whether you actually like it or not, all after saying "here's a quick review for you guys".

Allow me to make a recommendation:
  • Try it out for a week or two
  • Shower
  • Plan and structure your review (write it down if you really need to)
  • Dedicate a quiet reviewing area with good lighting and minimal distractions
  • If your webcam sucks, do a written review


2. This Thing Gives Great Vapour
No. It doesn't. Go have a look at some other reviews out there. Play them alongside your own. Compare. Your vapour production is comparable to that of a drive-thru coffee. Or maybe it's your lighting again. Or maybe that geriatric webcam: call the Antiques Road Show and make a buck or two off it and save yourself some time.


3. The Great Reveal
Some people have no patience. They'll start recording the review as the postman is walking up to the house. The reviewer is in his underthings. He starts talking before he even knows what he's reviewing. We're embarrassed for him as he can't open the box, or unwrap half the contents. And in the end we see that it comes with, yes you guessed it, exactly what the website said.


4. Have a Look Inside Here
When you point the open end of the atty towards the camera and say "I don't know if you can see in there", you might as well cut to an image of Betty White drop kicking Darth Vader. Or better yet, take a picture of the inside of the atty and cut to that.


5. Red Herrings
I like a good story as much as the next guy. That's why I read books and go to movies. Don't label your video as a review if you are going to talk about everything but the device for the first 6 minutes.


Final Thoughts
I'm honestly not trying to offend anybody out there who is posting these reviews. I appreciate the effort that so many people have put in to informing the vaping community. I'm not much of a reviewer myself, mainly because I mix most of my own juices and I'm content with the devices I own. But for those of you who are doing reviews, if you end up reading this, please think about why you are doing the review, before actually doing it.


Thanks so much for putting up with me, I hope you were entertained.
 

shamreez

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 25, 2011
128
5
Bristol UK
Well that was honest review on reviews.

It would not look good on you to name some bad reviewers but you could help us all by giving the name of some reviewers you found really good.

We can check than make sure we check them out before others.

But if you cannot even give a single name of a good reviewer than what ever you wrote does not have any credibility at all.
(Unless you make a review and post it to show how it is done)
 

bander68

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 26, 2011
738
438
Conroe, TX
You forgot something.
6. Turn down the grunge/rap/screamo/whatever that noise is. If we log on to your review, it's likely we are wanting to hear what you have to say. Perhaps it would be a good idea to check the sound levels of your video to see if what you have to say is actually audible. I have an extensive collection of music too, but I'm not going to blast it during my classes while I'm teaching and expect my students to hear a word I say. Next time you want to share your favorite music, label the video "Billy Bob's Favorite Screamo Crap That Shows Everybody What A Complete Musical Illiterate I Am (while opening a new eGo box)" and those of us who are looking for actual reviews will not waste our time trying to decipher your ....-addled ramblings and move on to someone who has a clue.

Does that fit into your review?
 

Craig645

Senior Member
Jan 7, 2011
72
2
Minnesota
Lol. I know what you mean.
I give 'em about 45 seconds and if they don't pull themselves together I shut the video off.
Mistress Nomad's " Ecigs For Broke People" should be mandatory viewing for anyone planning to post some type of video review.
They are very well organized.
I agree. These videos helped me alot as a newbie, they are bookmarked and I share them with other newbies. I don't really watch too many reviews personally but that may be because you never know what you're going to get. Maybe the people really are trying and doing their best. Nerve007 offers a critique to assist them with their future screenplays. I personally enjoyed the critique.
 

nerve007

Full Member
Dec 21, 2010
45
9
Canada
But if you cannot even give a single name of a good reviewer than what ever you wrote does not have any credibility at all.
(Unless you make a review and post it to show how it is done)


Well shamreez, I'm not too concerned with credibility.

To be even more honest, if I were to recommend any reviewer, I would be contradicting myself. Every review has a flaw. There are no perfect reviews.

Here's what I'll do though: I'll go through those headings and name people who do it right.

1. sl1pg8r from mainelyvapor on youtube, and GrimmGreen always seem prepared for a review. Their review area suits them. I can trust them to actually try the device or juice out for a while before reviewing it.

2. Again GrimmGreen actually knows the definition of great vapour, and he won't lie about it if the device isn't performing well.

3. VST from nicfitnation.com does unboxings, but because he's advertising the product, there are never any surprises. Its often more like a video brochure. Helpful and pleasant.

4. sl1pg8r has actually cut away to other images in a few reviews, but kept the review continuous and maintained the flow of it all.

5. Sorry, but everybody gets side tracked.


Hope that's helpful.
I know reviewing is a lot harder than it looks. I have to make a lot of technical presentations at school, so I am familiar with speaking to an audience. Not something I would like to do in my spare time, that's for sure
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread