Sadly, in small claims here you are limited to the value of the pet only. The value of our cats would be the adoption fee paid for them. And, you have to prove your case. Just too heartbreaking to go through this for what little would be gained. The value imposed on the other party would hardly be punitive (less than even vet bills in the case of injury). You can bet though, if ever my pet were injured and goes to the vet, I'd follow through with all actions available to recover cost of care. This would likely be punitive and result in some attention from the dog owner. Vet bills can be astronomical and I'd spare no expense.