Barry Hummel: Electronic cigarettes only help maintain addiction

Status
Not open for further replies.

BuGlen

Divergent
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2012
1,952
3,976
Tampa, Florida
An op-ed piece by some moralistic pediatrician who is anti-THR. Some good comments already, including one by Dr. Farsalinos, but this article could use more comments explaining to this guy exactly why he is SO wrong on this issue:

www.gainesville.com/
article/20131012/OPINION03/
131019949/1109/sports?p=1&tc=pg
 
Last edited:

pianoguy

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 4, 2009
4,816
3,909
Apple Valley, MN
Arghhh - I wanted to comment but I'm not on FB, so I couldn't. I'll post my comment here for posterity:

I had to laugh at the statement "Remember, no company that sells an addictive chemical for profit is interested in having you quit. THR is about market share, not public health." Before the advent of the e-cigarette, millions of smokers were in a box, an easy target for excessive taxation, and for lather-rinse-repeat ineffective pharmaceutical smoking cessation products and services. Imagine the impact to the bottom lines of federal and state governments if a significant percentage of smokers switch to the e-cigarette and are no longer subject to the onerous taxes. And to the bottom lines of pharmaceutical companies if suddenly there is little demand for their NRT's and other smoking cessation medications that have an abysmal success rate. And as a side effect, fewer sales of other drugs for COPD, asthma, migraines, blood pressure, etc. (a result of no longer inhaling tar and the chemical cocktail produced by tobacco smoke). So who is it exactly that doesn't want you to quit? And by quit, I mean quit smoking tobacco cigarettes. Switching to an alternative such as the e-cigarette is orders of magnitude less harmful than smoking, and provides an escape hatch from that box. Is it 100% safe? Of course not. Neither is getting in your car and driving to work, or drinking coffee. And certainly these products should not be sold to minors. Many states have enacted legislation to ban sales to minors. But it is funny that many of the alphabet soup health organizations have opposed such legislation.
 

BuGlen

Divergent
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2012
1,952
3,976
Tampa, Florida
Arghhh - I wanted to comment but I'm not on FB, so I couldn't. I'll post my comment here for posterity:

I had to laugh at the statement "Remember, no company that sells an addictive chemical for profit is interested in having you quit. THR is about market share, not public health." Before the advent of the e-cigarette, millions of smokers were in a box, an easy target for excessive taxation, and for lather-rinse-repeat ineffective pharmaceutical smoking cessation products and services. Imagine the impact to the bottom lines of federal and state governments if a significant percentage of smokers switch to the e-cigarette and are no longer subject to the onerous taxes. And to the bottom lines of pharmaceutical companies if suddenly there is little demand for their NRT's and other smoking cessation medications that have an abysmal success rate. And as a side effect, fewer sales of other drugs for COPD, asthma, migraines, blood pressure, etc. (a result of no longer inhaling tar and the chemical cocktail produced by tobacco smoke). So who is it exactly that doesn't want you to quit? And by quit, I mean quit smoking tobacco cigarettes. Switching to an alternative such as the e-cigarette is orders of magnitude less harmful than smoking, and provides an escape hatch from that box. Is it 100% safe? Of course not. Neither is getting in your car and driving to work, or drinking coffee. And certainly these products should not be sold to minors. Many states have enacted legislation to ban sales to minors. But it is funny that many of the alphabet soup health organizations have opposed such legislation.

Would you mind if I posted this comment for you and credited you for the content?
 

Anjaffm

Dragon Lady
ECF Veteran
Sep 12, 2013
2,468
8,639
Germany
What an utter bunch of horse manure that guy is spouting! Ewwwwww...

Great comments though!

I countered with this article - which states the facts, and not horse manure:
http://www.rationaloptimist.com/blog/don't-discourage-vaping.aspx

and could not help posting the PS to the Times article:

PS. A source in the European Parliament, after reading my article, added a fascinating detail:A further interesting point is the subtle role played by big pharma, who fund hundreds of various anti smoking organisations that curiously all lobbied against e-cigarettes. They, of course, want control of the market, have all the pharmaceutical grade production facilities and large corporate compliance departments whereas most existing e-cig companies are small scale start ups.
 
Last edited:

Bimini Twist

Twisted Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 27, 2012
1,661
5,843
67
Redneck Riviera
www.mboyd.com
Tobacco Prevention Network of Florida is funded by the Tobacco Settlement Trust Fund - a continuing payment from tobacco companies. If people move from cigarettes to non-big tobacco vaporizers/juices, they will loose their primary funding.

Hmm...

Their mission (as listed on their Web site) is to "advocate for tobacco prevention policies protecting Florida’s youth." Yet, in this very article, he gives statistics that support the fact that increased use of ecigs among youths coincides with decreased use of cigarettes among youths.

Hmm...
 

Bimini Twist

Twisted Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 27, 2012
1,661
5,843
67
Redneck Riviera
www.mboyd.com
I wasn't going to log into FB to add comments yesterday (I don't really like FB, but do have an account there). I changed my mind this morning and logged in to add some comments. However, the site keeps saying I'm not logged in even though the comment box clearly shows that I am:

Posting as my name (Not You?) [Reply]

Again, I'm not a fan of FB. Does that mean the site has closed comments on the article?

P.S. Here's the single line link.
Barry Hummel: Electronic cigarettes only help maintain addiction | Gainesville.com
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread