Battery Rattle

Status
Not open for further replies.

invisiblehand13

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 15, 2014
847
626
Woodville, WI
The battery wraps are designed for the friction of insertion and extraction, the material is not thin enough to become destroyed without some kind of user error, abuse, or sharp edges that simply cut the battery wrapping, not friction from moving up and down less than a few millimeters or insertion and extraction...are we still talking about batteries???? lol
 

invisiblehand13

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 15, 2014
847
626
Woodville, WI
definitely can't stand any battery rattle. I've even done a few crazy custom mods to make it so I don't have to adjust for battery rattle, cutting out custom pieces of hard foam, and the like....

I have always used some smaller o-rings when applicable as a super easy quick fix...like the fuhatten mods
 

LXXero

Full Member
Dec 15, 2014
16
28
Colorado, USA
yup, i do that on my turtleship mini with the o-rings, I put them under the delrin battery adjuster thing, though I'd been playing with hard foam to replace the delrin entirely and thus the need to ever adjust anything!

it only works on mods where you have a threaded delrin adjustment to eliminate rattle....you can basically replace it with a donut-shaped foam cutout, no more adjustments needed! I'm actually back to the o-rings at the moment, as the foam I had at the time was a bit too soft for my liking, however I just got some new stuff in that is intended for preventing rattle in RC model car batteries and I have a feeling this stuff is going to be perfect.
 

drunkenbatman

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 26, 2014
1,340
1,271
It's windy, USA
...just felt you were advising that it would destroy batteries when I have never had that effect in the mods that a more secure contact is preferable to eliminating battery rattle, I do not feel IMO that there is enough to destroy the battery wrapping (a very few mods with super tight tolerances aside) that could cause that damage before the life of the battery was entirely diminished...

I feel you, we're on the same spectrum just at different points on it (e.g., a scaredy-cat). I didn't intend to imply it'd cause it. It's definitely a remote thing, just not non-zero, and a mod designed for sliding the battery up and down appears to be adding unnecessary risk for little to no gain.

Stranger things have happened than a sharp bit of grit getting into the tube and getting ground into the wrap over and over. While I agree the wraps aren't tissue paper, I've seen wraps get knicked coming off the charger, knicked on a sharp edge of a mod, etc. One guy had a small tear at the edge of the wrap, a small thing that could have started peeling backwards; he wasn't sure how he did it, but his nails were like claws.

I'm entirely willing to reevaluate, but it'd generally require:

1. Having the actual benefit of a sliding battery be quantified -- a vague "we think it means you have to clean the bottom contacts less" is, well, vague.

2. Deciding that the quantified benefit was worth the increased risk, even if it's small.

And while it's late and I have your ear, what about the positive end now? While it's true that the contact surfaces completing a circuit will ionize the air and overtime that'll cause the contacts to get less conductive, aren't they just shifting this to the positive contact and atomizer contact? It's entirely possible I'm missing something, but erp...
 

Bunnykiller

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 17, 2013
17,431
77,270
New Orleans La.
IMO...you would need a RIDICULOUS amount of time to cause ANY damage to the wrap unless there is a SUPER tight tolerance in your mod which (with the exception of the vapor flask I have) I do not own any that battery rattle caused ANY damage to any of my mods or batteries and I think I have a few to make this claim...View attachment 404851View attachment 404852

no wonder why VTC4' and 5' are hard to get you got them all.... ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread