Out of the 15 years I spent smoking analogs, 10+ were menthol. I still indulge in a Camel Crushes (always crushed) once in a while, but I mostly vape. Great question though and I am happy it gives me an excuse to bust out and retry some ejuice I have sitting around I usually dont smoke, mainly because I have my preference, which is also listed below at the bottem of this post. My experience with the following Mint/Menthol ejuice is as follows:
Aroma Menthol A mild mint taste, semi-wet with a little menthol flavor. If you like a hint of mint then this might work for you.
Myvaporstore Menthol A moderate menthol taste though with little to no after taste. If you dont care about that fresh after taste or dont like that sort of thing, then this is a good choice.
Lux Menthol Like all Lux vapors I have tried, its very dry. A moderate menthol flavor. If you like dry tasting vapor with then go with Lux. As a side note, Lux has some amazing CS, is always very polite and generous with free/discounted stuff to customers. I wish I was into dry tasting vapors (They seems to have more PG/VG) because I am so impressed by the CS I get with my Lux orders. I would order more, but I just dont like the dry tasting ejuice. If you like how regular cigs have that dry smoke taste, then give Lux a shot.
Pillbox 38 Menthol A great tasting menthol. Like all Pillbox 38 ejuice I have tried there is a slight ammonia taste while the ejuice is heating up. This is more prevalent when using carts vs dripping. It goes away as soon as the juice gets hot though and you get some great menthol flavor. The Pillbox 38 ejuice is much more expensive than other ejuices but they seem to be very conscience about regulating exactly what goes into the product, so I guess you pay for that extra care. I would like to point out that Pillbox 38 is affiliated with Totally Wicked and personally I have had a lot of CS problems with this companies US division, which is why I no longer use or recommend them. After a few PM conversations with UK users, I feel that the UK division of TW is probably much better. Because of this, I am still considering buying directly from the UK TW and eating the extra cost of shipping.
Pillbox 38 Spearmint A great tasting ejuice if you like spearmint. This one is one of my favorites but again, I dont like TW USA. Unfortunately 30ml of this was wasted when the o-ring failed on the eyedropper that came with the ejuice and caused it to leak all over the place. Other users have reported similar issues so I recommend that with any TW ejuice, if you always leave the eyedropper cap on the bottle, even though it seems sealed with the o-ring, dont leave it on its side.
Cash True Menthol This is my GO-To menthol and is currently what I smoke 90% of the time I am vaping. It has a great menthol flavor, one of the best I have tried. You get a fresh taste afterward but it doesnt linger to the point of being annoying. You can get it in 60ml bottles for a little over $30 which is half the price of TW and in my opinion the flavor is exactly the same. I dont notice that hint of ammonia in the beginning too, which is an added bonus. I have had a good experience with puresmoker too as they always ship quickly and seem to be polite and customer oriented. I only wish they had more flavors to choose from.
I am waiting on my order from puresmoker that includes the new Cash Menthol Ice. Will update this post on how it is sometime in the near future. I expect the order will arrive this Saturday or Monday at the latest.