Billion Lives Needs Help

Status
Not open for further replies.

sonicdsl

Wandering life's highway
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 11, 2011
17,744
19,245
And in the NY Times article, it says:

"It’s a net broadly cast and woven of implications rather than of indisputable evidence, but — especially given the tobacco industry’s credibility problems — you’ll probably be inclined to think there’s some truth to the film’s allegations. And certainly you’ll feel for the smokers who testify movingly of being eager to try anything that might help them shake their habit. The film, though, doesn’t have any suggestions as to what the average viewer might do to help break the supposed conspirators’ blockade."

And I ask YOU, New York Times....... what do YOU suggest? Do you have a "supposed" answer? (yes, I'm mad)

Le sigh.


To you Salem, to you DBD, and to you, Clnire.... prior to even seeing the film, I had no expectations, and certainly no illusion that Aaron would have "the answers" to our dilemma(s). Having now seen it, I can say that this film highlights and emphasizes our trials, struggles, and tribulations, and THOSE are the things that the general public needs to know.

None of us have "the" answers, but to propagate misleading and false and damning information is not something that Mr. Beibert could stomach. He kept repeating to me, "It's just WRONG, WRONG, and I can not stand by and not tell the truth."

So, this film, as an be all and end all "answer" (which it's not), is the TRUTH. It's a loud and beautiful and impactful vision of the truth on the wide screen. It will cause people to think, and hopefully to act.

It is extremely risky on his part, in all honesty, and I hope that he, with all of our voices, continues to speak out in favor of what is right.


How many people is a BILLION...
Excellent post Kat, I wish I could like it more than once! :) I love that Aaron got behind this and took a risk to expose the truth!
 

clnire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 15, 2013
7,719
73,217
Florida
So, this film, as an be all and end all "answer" (which it's not), is the TRUTH. It's a loud and beautiful and impactful vision of the truth on the wide screen. It will cause people to think, and hopefully to act.

I agree completely! This film is not about a "solution", it is about pointing out the corruption and lies that are happening. I admire Mr Biebert for standing up and pointing this out.

I can't wait to see it! Although I read reviews, I don't blindly believe what they say. Too often something has received "not favorable" reviews and I have enjoyed it, movie, music, whatever. I also don't think the reviews are negative. As Deb said, "they" will twist anything the way "they" want. Hum, isn't that what this movie is about?
 

Katdarling

I'm still here on ECF... sort of. ;)
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 25, 2011
32,582
167,751
Utopia
I'm sorry, everyone, if I misrepresented, but my anger in the moment was directed at the article (not at anyone on the forum). I know full well that almost everyone on ECF has supported the effort, and consider myself among friends here.

My dismay was at this line:
"The film, though, doesn’t have any suggestions as to what the average viewer might do to help break the supposed conspirators’ blockade."

I can't speak for Aaron, or anyone, but if it were me, I'd never have presented answers because time will likely change any recommendations made at any moment. I believe that the impetus to learn, and then act appropriately based on current information and knowledge, is the very best that could be expected.

And I agree completely that everyone is entitled to their opinions, and maybe I was a bit reactivated having just come off of seeing the film, and by seeing how much of his heart and soul went into this. So if I was overly defensive in any way, I apologize for that too.

I hope you all have the opportunity to see this marvelous documentary.
 

Debadoo

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 18, 2012
18,052
133,969
Texas, near Fort Hood
Excellent post Kat, I wish I could like it more than once! :) I love that Aaron got behind this and took a risk to expose the truth!
JUP!

the movie has a great imdb rating so far after 1k+ reviews
lol well a lot of us gave it a 10 without having seen it, just to try to get it to come to people's attention. But I expect not all of the reviews are from that
 

Debadoo

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 18, 2012
18,052
133,969
Texas, near Fort Hood
Wahooo!! Louis' showing is now listed, so anyone in the area, please go buy your tickets so they get enough sold to have it!! This one is in walled lake, MI

https://www.tugg.com/events/a-billion-lives-dhtg

Mods.........Oliver said he was going to start a thread specifically for show listings, but I haven't found it, if there is one, please gimme a link and I can repost it there. thanks!
 

r77r7r

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Feb 15, 2011
    13,653
    22,632
    Pa,LandOfTaxes
    Wahooo!! Louis' showing is now listed, so anyone in the area, please go buy your tickets so they get enough sold to have it!! This one is in walled lake, MI

    https://www.tugg.com/events/a-billion-lives-dhtg

    Mods.........Oliver said he was going to start a thread specifically for show listings, but I haven't found it, if there is one, please gimme a link and I can repost it there. thanks!
    It'd be great if they PINNED this very important thread, when Oliver makes it!
     

    Fozzy71

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jul 7, 2016
    3,370
    11,737
    53
    8 Mile + 2.5
    Wahooo!! Louis' showing is now listed, so anyone in the area, please go buy your tickets so they get enough sold to have it!! This one is in walled lake, MI

    https://www.tugg.com/events/a-billion-lives-dhtg

    Mods.........Oliver said he was going to start a thread specifically for show listings, but I haven't found it, if there is one, please gimme a link and I can repost it there. thanks!
    thanks for posting this, got my ticket
     

    sonicdsl

    Wandering life's highway
    Supporting Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Aug 11, 2011
    17,744
    19,245
    Wahooo!! Louis' showing is now listed, so anyone in the area, please go buy your tickets so they get enough sold to have it!! This one is in walled lake, MI

    https://www.tugg.com/events/a-billion-lives-dhtg

    Mods.........Oliver said he was going to start a thread specifically for show listings, but I haven't found it, if there is one, please gimme a link and I can repost it there. thanks!
    I think @Oliver is traveling, so I'll page him with this post and see if he comes a-runnin'!
     

    Oliver

    ECF Founder, formerly SmokeyJoe
    Admin
    Verified Member
    Hi all - I don't think a sticky is a good idea - they tend to be invisible. @Debadoo, will you please create a new thread called "A Billion Lives Listings and show times" in the general discussion area?

    And, no, I've no problem with promoters adding to it if they wish.
     

    Debadoo

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    May 18, 2012
    18,052
    133,969
    Texas, near Fort Hood
    Hi all - I don't think a sticky is a good idea - they tend to be invisible. @Debadoo, will you please create a new thread called "A Billion Lives Listings and show times" in the general discussion area?

    And, no, I've no problem with promoters adding to it if they wish.
    thanks hun! Will do it now. Really appreciate your support of this.

    ETA: Link to the thread
    A Billion Lives Listings and Show Times
     
    Last edited:

    sonicdsl

    Wandering life's highway
    Supporting Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Aug 11, 2011
    17,744
    19,245

    Debadoo

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    May 18, 2012
    18,052
    133,969
    Texas, near Fort Hood
    • Like
    Reactions: DC2 and Kenna
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread