Geoff describes Butter Cream as a vanilla frosting. I have never tried that one, but I just received Butter Rum yesterday, and OMG, I LOVE THIS ONE. I was hesitant about buying this one. I don't drink. I drink virgin Pina Coladas, because I think the alcohol ruins the flavor, but I had to see what other people were raving about. Butter Rum is not in anyway a vanilla frosting. I really can't describe it though. You can taste the rum, but with the other flavors are blended so well that you really don't notice it. Does that make any since? Butter-Rum is not a real bold in your face type flavor, its just damn good.