Carto / Atty Cost

Status
Not open for further replies.

cyberwolf

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 22, 2009
2,217
403
Coral Springs, FL
In general, an atomizer will last much longer than a cartomizer. Of course your mileage may vary, but it's hard to imagine using a single cartomizer for a month or more, not so hard with an atomizer. Perhaps the most significant reason they are cheaper is that they are designed to be disposable, filled once and discarded. A $7-$10 price point would obviously not sell.
 

Buzzy

Super Member
ECF Veteran
May 19, 2010
333
7
Chicago
Dear Politically:
Hi, and welcome!
Ok, to answer your question - the structure of an atomizer stand-alone is quite different from the atomizer portion of a cartomizer. And they are more durable for the most part.
A single atomizer can with care last 6 months or more. Cartomizers do not tend to last more than 5 to 10 refills, then either the draw gets hard or there is a loss of vapor production or they begin to taste bad.

Ok, let's say you pay $8.95 for an atomizer and it does last six months (true sometimes they only last two weeks and sometimes two months. User variations and manufacturing tolerances account for that.) Then if you vape 4 carts per day (in my experience about equal to two cartomizers per day) you will use that one atomizer 720 times.

If you use two cartomizers per day, and each cartomizer lasts for 10 refills and there are 5 in a pack, one pack of cartomizers will last for 500 refills.

It actually averages out cost wise pretty closely. The real reason for choosing one over the other is which tastes best to you, imho. And there are many different opinions on that subject.

I've only had one atty fail since I began, and that was four months ago. I've two attys still going after 4 months. And cartridges are - again imho - much easier to clean, and just as easy to refill.
 

PoliticallyIncorrect

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 31, 2010
4,118
6,562
SoCal
...the structure of an atomizer stand-alone is quite different from the atomizer portion of a cartomizer. And they are more durable for the most part.

Ok, now that addresses the essence of what I was trying to get at. Their relative cost-effectiveness wasn't at issue (although your breakdown of the math was interesting and something to keep in mind). I was just looking at 5 atty/cart combinations--which is essentially what a carto is--versus a single atty, and wondering how one is a cost equal to the other from the manufacturer's point of view.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread