Cash True Menthol Replacement?

[Thalinor]

So I finally ran out of my stockpile of Cash True Menthol and need to find a replacement. They no longer sell the stuff which sucks, because IMO it was one of the best menthol's [that was] on the market.

Before you suggest something please consider the following:

Vegetable Glycerin for whatever reason gives me a sore throat; therefor whatever liquid you suggest needs to be based on Propylene Glycol.

This means most of Vermont Vapor liquids are out of the question as they mostly use VG.

I have tried Halo "NewPure" a long time ago and was not a fan as it was not menthol enough for my taste.

Not a big fan of the menthol's that are vanilla tasting like Cash Ice was, so please no blend menthol suggestions.


Spearmint tasting is OK as long as it has the menthol bite. I am really looking for less natural and more medium/moderate cool mint taste. As I said the best menthol I have found was Cash True Menthol, so if you have had that and found something similar, I would love to hear your suggestion!

The "Cool Rush" Altsmoke is selling in pre-filled carts is amazing, but they don't sell it in liquid form last time I checked.

Oh if it comes in 60ml bottles like Cash used to that would be amazing but not required.

Thanks in advance; Happy New Year!

 

[cappadoc]

I am a menthol devotee.

Have you tried the Tonic line from PS? I never tried Cash liquid, but am in love with Silver leaf menthol. Minthia is also good. BWB's menthol is good, but it has some VG.These are the best I've tried. Heard good things about Vapor Station also, but haven't tried it yet.

Are you a NO VG guy or is 20-30% OK?

 

[Twoo]

Only Menthol I've ever tried was Halo Menthol Ice. Definitely recommend it. Aside from that I can't really help you =/ This is coming from someone who smoked menthols for 7 years.

 

[ejoker]

moved to requests for opinions

 

[Jimi Mack]

Being a 35 year menthol user, I can suggest Tasty Vapor.

 

[player30]

Take this with a grain of salt, because I love Halo Truepure(newpure), but my first thougt was Halo Menthol Ice, because it is much more mentholly. Second is V4L Smilin' Menthol; it is also a strong menthol/spearmint flavor.

 

[Rosco]

I smoked Kool's for 40 years so I suppose I like menthol most of all.
I'm still on the hunt for my "favorite" menthol, but I have found that even with regular tobacco, if I had some menthol drops, it sure kicks that menthol hit up a notch or so.
Good luck..I'm paying close attention to this thread myself now.

 

[Thalinor]

So Rob @ AltSmoke suggested a place where I could find the Cool Rush Flavor in liquid rather then pre-filled carts. The website is LiquidXpress Hompage and they have both straight PV and VG versions of their Cool Rush flavor. I picked up the PV version and love the flavor, it's almost perfect but this stuff vapes very quickly. I have never had a liquid burn off so fast, even at low voltage. My guess is they add way too much water to the stuff. After going through 1/2 of a 30ml bottle in about 3 days [4x as fast as I usually go through eJuice] I decided to cut the stuff with straight PV by just filling the bottle back up to the top. In the end it cut it down too much and I lost a lot of the taste, but its now vaping at the rate of a normal premium eJuice.

If I had to guess this stuff is 15% Flavoring, 25% PV, and 60% water with nicotine added. It's too bad because it tastes so damn good. Several other reviews on their juice page state that their liquids vape really fast so I guess its just how they make the stuff.

Anyway, I just put in an order for more so that I can cut it with what I have, in hope to get some flavor back. I really think its time to just buy menthol crystals and make my own eJuice. The flavors I made with Totally Wicked's flavorless eJuice and the Lorann's Candy Flavoring they used to sell all came out great. Unfortunately it seems they now only sell Decadent Vapours flavoring which IMO sucks. I tried 5 different Decadent Vapours flavors and all had awful after tastes and were very dirty tasting. Its hard to describe. Anyway, I am sure mixing w/ menthol crystals should not be too much more difficult.

I ended up having to pick up a pack of Analogs a few weeks ago for a winter camping trip. I smoked the whole pack over two days, which was now almost 14 days ago and had no problems wanting to go back to get a second pack when the first was finished. I really think vaping helps with not only quitting, but to help the body break the addiction part of smoking altogether. After that weekend I did not even vape for a few days as I had run out of eJuice and did not suffer any withdrawal symptoms. I did however find a new Analog flavor, Camel Silvers, which were basically Camel Menthol's with the same crush bead in the Camel Crushes so you get even more menthol. Damn these Analog companies are trying everything to keep people smoking. I have to admit they were really good, but not as good as vaping IMO.

@cappadoc

No VG, not mixed, nothing. If I vape it too much my throat gets sore and I loose my voice. It's odd because I am not allergic to it or anything else for that matter, but when I vape the stuff my throat goes to hell.