I got to try the tobacco #1 today - didn't have a vast amount of time but my new atty got here so I used it asap! lol
Mine was 12mg - vaped on a 3.7v 510
Very very reminiscent of 'candy floss' or 'cotton candy' - actually it tastes like the SMELL of it - that burnt sugar, delicious smell you get at fairgrounds. This is extremely light - by which I mean 'clean' in the mouth, no reisdue on the tongue - which I've come to expect from BASIC. Some VG can leave a waxy/oily residue in the mouth but BASIC never has. I always find the BASIC juices a very clean vape experience, though if you're looking for heavy ( its a different mouth-feel, the flavors are quite strong but feel light, its hard to describe it accurately) flavors this isn't it.
The tobacco taste part is lighter than the cotton candy smell but its there alright. As soon as I opened this bottle my nose was happy I have to say - I was actually looking forward to vaping it based on the smell alone. There is no artificial taste in this either, no weird chemical sweetener taste, no sharp tastes, just very clean very pleasant.
I can see why this one is the one most like so far by reveiwers - I haven't tried the other 2 yet though. I remain impressed with the BASIC range though, its one of the cleanest tasting VGs out there imo and the flavors (mostly fruits up til now) are extremely nice.
This is a sample pack of 3 x 3ml bottles - and it cost $5 (it costs $5 to ship so I suggest buying something else as well just to justify the shipping lol)- so how could I NOT try it?