Yeah I don't remove the whole thing with my fingernail, it would certainly rip off, but just to get it started for sure. I haven't tried to take it off without the soap/water, but I couldn't imagine getting it off without some lubricating assistance. That said, the last time I removed the tank it took me 10 minutes total, just going slow and being careful. It definitely does not come off easy. Sorry couldn't be of more help