This one was pretty nice. Its not a sweet caramel which is good for me. Maybe its muted because of the tobacco flavor but its a really nice smooth caramel flavor. I dont get much of the tobacco but that's what Im thinking the mellowness of the flavor is. Ive tried a few caramels from other places before and this is a very nice one. Better than the rest. Its not overpowering and it has a great th as well. I was filling it and first testing it out in my class a while ago and the kid next to me thought it smelled better in vapor form than juice form. I thought it smelled good either way. mmm tasty. Im rockin it on a pt with a cc at 24mg (all the flavors Ive reviewed are 24mg). Does it sound like something you'd like? try it out. All these flavors are complex and awesome!