Consumer Reports Comment

Status
Not open for further replies.

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
I just got my issue of Consumer Reports and pg.39-

The Worst New Threat to Kids

Manufacturers are marketing e-cigarettes in fruit and candy flavors but not making packages tamper resistant leading to a

sky-rocketing number of poisonings from concentrated liquid nicotine.
***********
Is this their opinion or fact?

Yes, .......................................... If it doubled from 1 to 2 that is.

Odd thing, almost every bottle I have, excluding drip needle tips have child resistant caps.:glare:
 

David1975

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 30, 2014
562
707
Northlake, IL, USA
I for one am kind of tired seeing "it's for the kids" articles left and right. I'm 38 years old, when I grew up I used a lawnmower, chain saw, pellet guns and wrist rocket. Used fire works, road a skateboard and bike without armor and GUESS WHAT.... I'M STILL ALIVE. At what point do we stop limiting our actions to protect everyone's kid, and start teaching parents how to PARENT again? I'm waiting for the day we bubble wrap kids at birth and store them in a clean bubble for 18 years, then wonder why they never "grew up" and can't take personal responsibility for their own actions. Sorry.. rant over.
 

KODIAK (TM)

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 31, 2014
1,898
4,983
Dead Moose, AK
I for one am kind of tired seeing "it's for the kids" articles left and right. I'm 38 years old, when I grew up I used a lawnmower, chain saw, pellet guns and wrist rocket. Used fire works, road a skateboard and bike without armor and GUESS WHAT.... I'M STILL ALIVE. At what point do we stop limiting our actions to protect everyone's kid, and start teaching parents how to PARENT again? I'm waiting for the day we bubble wrap kids at birth and store them in a clean bubble for 18 years, then wonder why they never "grew up" and can't take personal responsibility for their own actions. Sorry.. rant over.

You'll get used to it. :)

But don't fall for the hype that governments, people in power and most media outlets actually care about "children". Kids are merely a convenient tool used to pull the heart strings of the general populace for the sole purpose of implementing a broader agenda.
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
http ://www.komonews.com/news/local/Warning-to-Parents--Just-One-Mouthful-of-Liquid-Nicotine-in-Kids-is-Serious-275484471.html

Just for example I found this - Sept 2014 in Washington state.

"The total number of calls to the center about e-cigarettes is up 600 percent compared with recent years. There’s also a staggering increase in the number of kids exposed to serious levels of nicotine."

"So far this year 83 children have been over-exposed to liquid nicotine, compared with 50 exposures in 2013."

"And it's not just young ones who end up over-exposed to liquid nicotine. Month to month, the number of calls to the poison center have doubled, sometimes even tripled since 2012."

Again, 'calls' could be anything from 'what amount is dangerous?' 'What are the symptoms IF...?' 'What do I do IF....?'

And more importantly - Scare stories like this, likely generate more calls than any actual incidents. So I would be expecting the number of calls to go to even 5-10X "from 20XX year!!"

It has always had some 'slant' but Consumer Reports since about mid 1980's made a sharp Left turn toward activism - at which for me (dropping the subscription) ... the 'pros' of the actual consumer reporting/testing on goods were overweighed by the 'cons' - sometimes true cons of a different definition - on their opinions - where their subjectivity overwhelmed their objectivity.

I find Amazon ratings just as dependable - dropping the 5 stars as fanboys and girls and the 1 stars as competitors or fanboys and girls of the competitors - using the 2,3 and 4 star ratings as a fairly accurate and objective estimate. CNET close to the same but used to be better than it is now, imo.
 

David1975

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 30, 2014
562
707
Northlake, IL, USA
I agree. Just waiting for the day more people see this. Funny, I used to think America was "Of the people, by the people, for the people".... Seem the "people" have become sheep..... And the government the wolves.
I tend to see this more NOW than I used too, due in part to the FDA. The FDA tells us that GMO's are ok to eat because they have "not been shown to be hazardous", while telling us e-cigs are bad because "they have not been proven safe". Aren't rules supposed to fit all situations? Seems to be double talk when groups like or dislike items for one reason or another ($$$).
 

twgbonehead

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Apr 28, 2011
3,705
7,020
MA, USA
"The total number of calls to the center about e-cigarettes is up 600 percent compared with recent years. There’s also a staggering increase in the number of kids exposed to serious levels of nicotine."

Month to month, the number of calls to the poison center have doubled, sometimes even tripled since 2012."

If the number of calls only doubled, month-to-month,
and they had only 1 call in Jan 2012
This would mean they now have over 2 million calls/month.

That's a crock.
 

Lillie Bennett

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 3, 2014
245
333
Virginia
True you can make just about any argument with statistics and Consumer Reports are most definitely guilty of following the money.

Most juice bottles have child proof caps but tanks and RDAs do not and most leak somewhat if at least through the air holes. Also most RDA caps and drip tips simply pull off and are easily swallowed.

So there is some danger but control and prevention belongs to parents.
 

M4rtin

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 15, 2014
200
685
New Jersey, USA
The argument that e-cigarettes makers are focusing their marketing to children with candy and fruit flavors is ignorant and sensationalism. Adults like candy and fruit flavors, too. Where's the outcry for the fruit and candy flavors in alcoholic drinks? Same thing.

This is propaganda from Big Tobacco and Big Pharmacy.

That is A HUGE YES! They are using that angle, because I keep seeing more and more references in regards to this. Pathetic! I would have used other words, but seems they are using the advertising to children angle.
 

Davey59

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
799
857
Monroe WA
I for one am kind of tired seeing "it's for the kids" articles left and right. I'm 38 years old, when I grew up I used a lawnmower, chain saw, pellet guns and wrist rocket. Used fire works, road a skateboard and bike without armor and GUESS WHAT.... I'M STILL ALIVE. At what point do we stop limiting our actions to protect everyone's kid, and start teaching parents how to PARENT again? I'm waiting for the day we bubble wrap kids at birth and store them in a clean bubble for 18 years, then wonder why they never "grew up" and can't take personal responsibility for their own actions. Sorry.. rant over.

Absolutely agree!

Thing of it is, you are forgetting that the leftist mantra is "it takes a village" what they are not telling you is the villagers have torches and are very angry. Who are they angry with? whomever they are pointed at on a given day.

I stopped taking Consumer Reports seriously many years ago. I think they are on the take, can be had, are often had, then try and take us. A real shame but as most good ideas, regulatory and social programs they are soon .......ised by the power hungry and greedy.
 

Ed_C

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 11, 2013
2,675
3,406
Seligman, MO
I for one am kind of tired seeing "it's for the kids" articles left and right. I'm 38 years old, when I grew up I used a lawnmower, chain saw, pellet guns and wrist rocket. Used fire works, road a skateboard and bike without armor and GUESS WHAT.... I'M STILL ALIVE. At what point do we stop limiting our actions to protect everyone's kid, and start teaching parents how to PARENT again? I'm waiting for the day we bubble wrap kids at birth and store them in a clean bubble for 18 years, then wonder why they never "grew up" and can't take personal responsibility for their own actions. Sorry.. rant over.

Just because you survived all of the above, that doesn't mean that all kids did. The fact that I didn't have a car seat growing up and lived to tell about it, doesn't mean that kids didn't die needlessly and it doesn't mean that car seats aren't a good thing. All anyone is talking about is child-proof caps. If kids can be made more safe by simple means, I don't think we should decline because we somehow feel that not having our juice in whatever type of bottle we choose is an infringement of our rights. I'm sorry but when it comes to kids, I don't think there is an acceptable loss.
 

Ed_C

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 11, 2013
2,675
3,406
Seligman, MO
You'll get used to it. :)

But don't fall for the hype that governments, people in power and most media outlets actually care about "children". Kids are merely a convenient tool used to pull the heart strings of the general populace for the sole purpose of implementing a broader agenda.

Here we go with the sweeping generalization again. Assigning motivation to various, large groups of people that we don't know. I'm amazed at how some of you know what so many people think.
Logical Fallacies» Sweeping Generalisation Fallacy
 

Davey59

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
799
857
Monroe WA
Here we go with the sweeping generalization again. Assigning motivation to various, large groups of people that we don't know. I'm amazed at how some of you know what so many people think.
Logical Fallacies» Sweeping Generalisation Fallacy

Well sure, but that in itself does not make it any less true.

I am not a universal negative guy and just because something is BS and agenda driven does not mean an individual caught up in the movement does not care.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread