I am new to vaping (3 months) but I am now completely off analogs and almost all the way off nicotine in my juices. I have been experimenting at home with different things and I think I have found a great mix. Now I was not a menthol smoker when I smoked analog cigs but I found that the only thing that gave any me any throat hit in my home recipes was mint. Yes believe it or not, Creme de Menthe candy oil from your local craft store or Lorann online mixed sparingly with straight up store bought USP Grade VG gave me what I was looking for in a zero nic vape. I got clouds of vapor, a pretty decent throat hit and a nice minty aftertaste. It felt like I was smoking a Menthol Light cigarette. Again, not my favorite style of smoke back in the day but if you're looking for a zero nicotine vape with a good throat hit, it's worth a try. Hope this helps someone else out there...!!!