Fruit flavor experts I need help before I lose my mind

[Magikhat]

I need some advice please

I need help finding a watermelon DIY flavoring that tastes like real watermelon

i need help finding a cantaloupe DIY flavoring that tastes like cantaloupe.
i tried TFA cantaloupe and it is very disappointing.

I also need to know where to get menthol to add to the watermelon.

what is the best?

 

[nickgonzo]

I have tried the following Watermelons; FW, TFA, HealthCabin, Capella

My favorite is Capella Sweet Watermelon. I recommend it with TFA coming in 2nd. I'm unsure of there being a true Watermelon taste, most have the candy flavor IMO.

TPA has menthol and I think they do Koolada as well. I know for sure highdesertvapes has both

 

[Iffy]

The few WMs I've tried tasted more like rind than fruit.

 

[Magikhat]

I will give it a try. Thanks Do you know what % to mix with for the capellas sweet watermelon? And what % menthol to mix with it?

 

[subversive]

I add 15 drops of TPA's menthol to a 30ml bottle for a strong menthol.

 

[nickgonzo]

I like cap sweet watermelon at 10%

 

[Magikhat]

For the watermelon should I buy EM? Or Koolata or some other menthol to mix with it?
I want it to add a cool menthol

 

[Jimi D.]

Nature Flavors will be my last resort. I've tried everything so far. Just too artificial tasting.

 

[The White Rabbit]

TFA Cantaloupe is quite realistic. And I'll also vote for Capella Sweet Watermelon as an excellent watermelon, TFA's Watermelon is awful to me.

 

[Magikhat]

The TFA cantaloupe I got from wizardlabs tasted like hardly anything. Seemed so weak and watered down. Still looking for another cantaloupe. Maybe natures flavors