Halo - All Three Menthols: Cool, Newpure & Menthol Ice

Status
Not open for further replies.

Remie

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 16, 2009
780
894
Florida
Although I'm relatively new to vaping I was able to quit a lifelong "die-hard menthol" analong habit overnight, and I haven't looked back.

I knew from the start that my major quest would be finding a menthol that was actually menthol, not mint, not sweet, not minty-sweet, not candy flavored or food-type mint flavors... I needed a liquid that would be my brand, flavor, taste (whatever you choose to call it) - I needed something that I could get attached to and depend on to be my "go-to", all-day vape, in the same way I depended on my analog brand to always taste the same. If this was going to work for me and finally be the magic that enabled me to quit after virtually never knowing life without smoking, I knew I needed something to depend on.

After trying to be satisfied with or get comfortable and attached to the various "menthols" and "mint" sample sized liquids I've ordered, I was just about to give up and resign myself to the fact that no such liquid existed.

I finally ventured from the safety of the New Members section of the boards and started reading about suppliers and reading reviews of e-liquids determined to learn more. I was running low on e-juice and waiting for orders that thanks to the post office, never got delivered.

I found Halo and instantly placed my first order for Menthol Ice.

I received my order in two days, complete with a 10ml sample of Freedom.

I started vaping the Menthol Ice and instantly knew - this is a very high quality product and unlike anything else! Within a day of using Menthol Ice I knew I had to try more of this stuff!

I had questions about the differences between the three menthols offered by Halo. It's what prompted me to reach out through their web-site and ask about the other flavors after experiencing Menthol Ice. I placed my second order and thanks to Jay Blazio's amazing customer service, two days later I had both the Cool and Newpure, as well as another 10ml sample bottle of Freedom. Awesome.

I've seen many people ask about the differences between these three flavors and I'm going to do my best to describe each one and how they compare to each other.

I'm using the Joye 510 and to compare all three of these flavors I've used fresh carts and clean attys. I've had three 510s assembled and filled with each flavor so I could vape a little on one and switch to the others at will. I've also vaped one flavor for hours to a full day before switching to another. I wanted this review to be as objective and descriptive as possible in the hope that I could describe each one to the best of my ability.

I'm using the 24mg strength in all three flavors.

Overall Impression I know I've said a lot of this in my first review of Menthol Ice and I've seen most everyone say the same thing, but I have to say it again:

Halo Raises The Bar and Sets A Whole New Standard : The product is packaged in a blue glass bottle, safety sealed and labeled with the flavor, Nicotine Level, Volume, Born On Date and Lot Code. The dropper top is child proof and the dropper itself is marked in graduations of .25 to 1.0 ml.
It's obvious that this company takes quality control seriously, and I appreciate that. I also know that when I place my next order for Newpure, (Menthol Ice, Cool, Freedom...) my next bottle will be exactly what I wanted and expected. It will be manufactured to standard in a professional, quality controlled laboratory right here in the USA.

All three menthols are crystal clear and colorless.

These menthol liquids are not "flavors" that you can smell in the bottle to get an impression of what it will taste like. There is virtually no discernible or overpowering smell to this e-liquid. It's not like any e-liquid I've tried to date. What is obvious instantly though, is the clean, purity of this e-liquid. There is no need to shake the bottle before using it, it doesn't separate, there is no particulate matter of any kind floating in it.

The flavors of this e-liquid are complex and at the same time, subtle. To me, vaping this liquid is the way a "good smoke" should be. I know that sounds strange, but I remember those times when I'd light up an analog and thoroughly enjoy the entire experience, from the taste to the smell on the exhale, my ever present smoke rings and the almost euphoric relief those nasty little fire-sticks brought me. Over the years, at almost 2 packs a day, those moments were rare indeed. I'd developed a love/hate relationship with smoking (the hate growing more intense as time went on) and accepted the fact that I was just one of those die-hard people with no hope of ever being able to quit.

E-liquid will never taste exactly like my analogs: This is my opinion and Halo is no exception. That said - I don't ever want to taste an analog again! Halo tastes like what I always wanted from smoking. I get all of the gratification and reward with none of the nastiness. I can taste the menthol, I can taste the variations between the three flavors and as time goes on, each of them have their own merits and they all keep getting better.

I can't imagine why I used to hold so firm to the fact that I "loved" my analogs. I love vaping so much more than I ever enjoyed smoking.

The first time you try one of Halo's menthols you may be surprised and not be instantly blown away like I was. You may wonder what all the buzz is about and wonder why people are raving about this liquid.

If you've been used to thick, sweet, strong or lingering flavors, this e-liquid will be a completely different experience. Give yourself a chance to settle in with this product. During my first week with this e-liquid, the more I vaped it, the more I liked it. Every time I thought I wanted a "different flavor", I barely finished a cartridge before I was topping it off with Halo, or reaching for a clean cartridge and filling it up with Halo.

No filmy coating in your mouth or throat - it's so clean. I don't feel the need to drink tons of Iced Tea or water when I vape Halo. I now drink when I'm thirsty, not because my vaping is leaving me feeling dehydrated, thirsty, filmy, coated or dry.

Awesome Vapor Production: Across the board. All three menthols and Freedom. Amazing vapor. I can sit and blow "smoke rings" to my hearts content. I exhale then speak, and a little more vapor comes out of my mouth! Where does all that vapor come from!? Seriously copious amounts of vapor.

I find the differences between the three menthols subtle. I don't think anyone looking for a genuine menthol vape would be disappointed with any of these. I have yet to figure out which of the three is my absolute favorite. I enjoy them all!

Menthol Ice: Gentle, soft, refreshingly mild menthol with a slight hint of Vanilla. I'm not all about the slamming throat hit and this has a very mild throat hit. It's extremely smooth all around. I experience the vanilla on the exhale and I get a hint of it when I exhale the vapor and happen to breathe some in through my nose. I can vape this all day, it's satisfying, clean and pure.


Newpure: A brighter fresher menthol. This flavor is what a menthol cigarette should taste like. There is no overpowering tobacco taste, there is nothing artificial at all about this flavor. It's clean, pure menthol deliciousness. After vaping this for a while, I again taste a very slight hint of vanilla. It took me a while to pin it down, but I believe it's an ever-so-slight hint, on the exhale. Excellent all day vape. Perfect throat hit for me. If I were forced to choose, I think this one wins by a hair. Over time, I experience more complexities from this flavor.

Cool: This is literally a cooling mild menthol. To me, this is the least complex of the three. Over time, this flavor does round out for me and I love it. I enjoy this one because of the pure cooling taste. Again, I think of this flavor as a genuine menthol. This menthol is only slightly "brighter" than the others overall, while still not being anywhere near sweet or candy-ish and not overpowering. I do feel the menthol in my head after I vape this, but not in a sinus-clearing blast. Another completely pure all day vape.

I'd be hard pressed to only choose from one of these, they are all that good. I love having a consistent liquid to rely on. I've learned to expect and look forward to them and they deliver every time.

Thank you Halo! I'm even loving the Freedom samples and I never thought I'd like a "tobacco" liquid. I topped off a Newpure cartridge with Freedom and went to heaven for a few minutes, it was awesome, just the variation I needed when I thought I needed a variation!


Taste is subjective, but this e-liquid is all around tasteful.

I don't want to find myself without this liquid, it's what I've come to rely on.









 

stubear62

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 27, 2009
2,712
8
Myrtle Beach, SC
BRAVO!! BRAVO!! Excellent review my dear.
That was so good, I felt like I was you tasting those menthols. I don't even like menthols.BUT, Ido like the newpure and I will be trying the other two as I find the flavors from Halo's liquid refreshing yet subtle.
Its like the newpure could very well be compared to newport light's. I use to smoke those a long time ago and it just reminded me about them.
I will try the 56 and bella liquids too. The smooth I just can't try for the ginger won't like me no matter how small of an amount is in it. LOL
Good job, keep it up!!
 

Remie

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 16, 2009
780
894
Florida
Thank you!

Hi Stubear! Did you do a video review on Halo? I smoked Newport Light 100's - it was my only brand for as long as I can remember... and yes - I think all of Halo's menthols are the best as far as "smoking a menthol! :) I was having a little euphoric recall writing that :lol:

I'm kind of intrigued by this ginger taste everyone is describing - and I do really like the Freedom, even though it's not menthol!

I read something somewhere about Halo developing some "coffee" and "fruit" flavors - I can only imagine how awesome those would be!
 

stubear62

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 27, 2009
2,712
8
Myrtle Beach, SC
Hey Rimie,
Yes I did a video review on the freedom and newpure eliquids from halo.
Don't tell me you didn't like them? I do all my reviews for the noobs and this way they will know what is good from my opinion on the suppliers I buy from. Even though they prob. go "who is that idiot doing that review?" LOL
I just want to help EVERYONE know whats good and where to go for the best out there. I believe that Halo has done a VERY GOOD job on these flavors and I cna't wait till I try some others..

So much juice, so little time to do reviews.. LOL8-o
 

Remie

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 16, 2009
780
894
Florida
Hey Rimie,
Yes I did a video review on the freedom and newpure eliquids from halo.
Don't tell me you didn't like them? I do all my reviews for the noobs and this way they will know what is good from my opinion on the suppliers I buy from. Even though they prob. go "who is that idiot doing that review?" LOL
I just want to help EVERYONE know whats good and where to go for the best out there. I believe that Halo has done a VERY GOOD job on these flavors and I cna't wait till I try some others..

So much juice, so little time to do reviews.. LOL8-o

lol - stu, no, no... I saw it on youtube when I was searching for info! I liked it! I think you did a great job - and I left you a comment :) I'd already been using Halo when I found it, so of course I had to watch it!

I spend a lot of time cruising around youtube trying to watch videos that people post about e-juice, the 510, etc... :) (trying being the operative :lol: have you seen some of the stuff people post just trying to get hits? omg :lol: )
 

Keebler

Full Member
Dec 18, 2009
59
14
49
Clearwater, FL
I just received my order for Menthol ice last night. I was going to write my own review but I could not have put it any better that this OP. I got 30ml of Menthol Ice and a 10 ml sample of newpure. I used a clean atty and carts for the first try. Menthol Ice will def be my all day vape, esp as a once diehard menthol smoker. Smoooth, cool, and good vapor. Liquid is crystal clear and wicks well using the blue foam in my carts, though thick enough that you may have to turn it cart up if you vape too fast. Not so thin it will flood the atty, so I may retry the straw mod with this one.
The Newpure was stronger, with a definite aftertaste of candy canes. I almost believed I would crunch down on one when I vaped it. I will be using this as a pallette cleanser, since my other flavor right now is Cappuccino, and after a while I can't taste it. I recommend one of these with a dedicated atty for anyone that likes those flavors, ie capp, caramel, toffee, chocolate. Vape on this and the smoother, sweeter flavors come right back.
Halo has definitely raised the bar and I will not be buying Chinese junk anymore. At this great price I can afford to be choosy:thumb:
 

River

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 11, 2009
591
36
Independence, KY USA
Great review.

I have only tried newpure so far but I really liked it. So much so that I finally quit using freedom after nine days straight to switch over to it for a bit.

I have been on a Halo break because I've got piles of Dekang to go through and get rid of before I can justify restocking my supplies.

Seriously you have to do one or the other because if you don't the dekangs taste kinda musty and dank if you are doing them at the same time and are tasting the difference on a day to day or hour by hour basis.
 

Keebler

Full Member
Dec 18, 2009
59
14
49
Clearwater, FL
Great review.

I have been on a Halo break because I've got piles of Dekang to go through and get rid of before I can justify restocking my supplies.

Seriously you have to do one or the other because if you don't the dekangs taste kinda musty and dank if you are doing them at the same time and are tasting the difference on a day to day or hour by hour basis.

Yeah, my Dekang Cappuccino alternates between tasting like foot and ..., and i still have 15ml left to go. I did discover that a few drops of Menthol Ice in the same cart takes out some of the foot, still trying to get rid of the ....
 

nyabzns

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 26, 2009
602
142
55
Midwest , USA
I am really psyched to get my Menthol Ice and am now wanting to order the other 2 menthol flavors, and the Bella too! This is going to be my first time vaping and Menthol Ice will be my first juice refill. I am feeling good about my choice!

I started about 6 months ago and I wish the Halo stuff had been available then. Nothing I've tried is as good as this stuff. I've tried some flavors that were horrible and admit some tobacco flavors that weren't to bad and I'd use again if I had to but as long as Halo keeps up the quality on their stuff I'd have a hard time going back to anything else.
 

Remie

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 16, 2009
780
894
Florida
I just received my order for Menthol ice last night. I was going to write my own review but I could not have put it any better that this OP. I got 30ml of Menthol Ice and a 10 ml sample of newpure. I used a clean atty and carts for the first try. Menthol Ice will def be my all day vape, esp as a once diehard menthol smoker. Smoooth, cool, and good vapor. Liquid is crystal clear and wicks well using the blue foam in my carts, though thick enough that you may have to turn it cart up if you vape too fast. Not so thin it will flood the atty, so I may retry the straw mod with this one.
The Newpure was stronger, with a definite aftertaste of candy canes. I almost believed I would crunch down on one when I vaped it. I will be using this as a pallette cleanser, since my other flavor right now is Cappuccino, and after a while I can't taste it. I recommend one of these with a dedicated atty for anyone that likes those flavors, ie capp, caramel, toffee, chocolate. Vape on this and the smoother, sweeter flavors come right back.
Halo has definitely raised the bar and I will not be buying Chinese junk anymore. At this great price I can afford to be choosy:thumb:

:thumb: Awesome! This liquid is SO unique it seems we all pick up on something different in each flavor! I don't experience the candy-cane with Newpure, but maybe once my taste-buds do some more recovering, I will! The thing I love the best is that whatever I'm tasting in these menthols, there is nothing sickeningly sweet about them.

I was really, really getting disconcerted with (what to me was) the sickeningly sweet mints and menthols. I really wanted to like the watermelon, cherry and strawberry flavors I ordered a while ago... :( I topped off a Menthol Ice cart with a little watermelon - and ... I liked it! Now when I feel like trying a "flavor" I am adding one of Halo's menthols to it :thumb:

I found a way to use up some of the e-juices I know I'll never re-order :D

I think I'd like a good cappuccino/coffee vape - I can't wait until Halo introduces coffee flavors!

I use the straw mod and it works great with this smoke-juice. I think you're right about the consistency :)

Remie
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread