Status
Not open for further replies.

bmeyer46

Full Member
Sep 3, 2010
34
22
Missouri
Without doing the research you suggested we do, I have a question (my bad in advance?) Has anybody who has strictly vaped (not used other tobacco related products) been tested for any of that and come up positive? And how long had it been since they'd done anything except vape? That would be interesting to find out.

I haven't smoked since Sept 4, 2010.
 

cookiebun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2011
1,296
616
Central Ohio
Without doing the research you suggested we do, I have a question (my bad in advance?) Has anybody who has strictly vaped (not used other tobacco related products) been tested for any of that and come up positive? And how long had it been since they'd done anything except vape? That would be interesting to find out.

Yes I recall reading such a thread. He was tested for nicotine for insurance or a job, I can't recall. He'd been vaping for a long time but still used nicotine in his juice.
The tests don't distinguish the source of the nicotine.
 

cookiebun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2011
1,296
616
Central Ohio
ok so tell me this....if you are on a nicotine patch that is delivering nicotine would you test positive for the cotine then...so if it doesnt then your are damned if you do and damned if you don't.

This is exactly why some of my co workers said they'd just keep on smoking rather than try to use an ecig.
 

bmeyer46

Full Member
Sep 3, 2010
34
22
Missouri
Cotinine is a metabolic byproduct of nicotine. Nicotine replacement medications produce cotinine just as tobacco does.

SOOOO...you may be chewing the gum and on the patches and will still test positive even if you aren't smoking.

so to ME....if vaping produces a postitive as well as FDA approved NRT methods, then how could the insurance companies discriminate against the method you chose to quit analogs?
 

GIMike

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 15, 2009
1,822
719
Around OKC, OK
Cotinine is a metabolic byproduct of nicotine. Nicotine replacement medications produce cotinine just as tobacco does.

SOOOO...you may be chewing the gum and on the patches and will still test positive even if you aren't smoking.

so to ME....if vaping produces a postitive as well as FDA approved NRT methods, then how could the insurance companies discriminate against the method you chose to quit analogs?

Almost all other ways are tested and approved by the FDA. Ecigs haven't been? That's my guess.

BardicDruid, you still using that pen style PV? :)
 

LibertyValance

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 28, 2011
112
37
Tampa, FL
In general, if you commit fraud on an insurance application they might not have to pay. (Example not mentioning you have cancer).

However, generally speaking a mistake, or "forgetting" to mention something will not disqualify you from collecting. So if someday you need to collect on the insurance, it will be there. But the insurance company may deduct the extra premium they would have charged you, had you checked the correct box - from the amount of the insurance paid out. Because its not fraud if you answer wrong by mistake, or depending on how its worded, decide an ecig doesn't meet the criteria.

By the way, you don't need to worry about "integrity" when dealing with a health insurer, since there are not any that know the what the word means. So I say "no" on mine and sleep just fine.
 

GIMike

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 15, 2009
1,822
719
Around OKC, OK
I'm still looking for the amount of eggplant you'd have to eat to fail a nic test.

I only eat my eggplants when they're fried up like squash. So I'd think if I ate enough to fail a nic test, I'd probably have more serious problems to be worried about. Like obesity and cholesterol problems.
 

cookiebun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2011
1,296
616
Central Ohio
There is also another problem with this since continine can be present in non smokers who live in homes where other people smoke.
Personally I think it's a non issue, since the argument is about SMOKING or CHEWING tobacco. Not nicotine.

Well for insurance purposes there is no difference.
They get away with that. You think that's fair?
 

cookiebun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2011
1,296
616
Central Ohio

JustaGuy

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 19, 2011
3,483
91,179
Beyond The Sea
Cotinine is a metabolic byproduct of nicotine. Nicotine replacement medications produce cotinine just as tobacco does.

SOOOO...you may be chewing the gum and on the patches and will still test positive even if you aren't smoking.

so to ME....if vaping produces a postitive as well as FDA approved NRT methods, then how could the insurance companies discriminate against the method you chose to quit analogs?

There's one big difference between e-cig and NRTs - NRTs are "in" with the medical/legal system and sold by BP. That brings us back to money. You can quit smoking "our way" or your way, in which case we collect more insurance money from you. The FDA gets money from BP.
 

cookiebun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 6, 2011
1,296
616
Central Ohio
Awww, blocked by our firewall. Well, I think I get the jist from the title. Eating way too many fried eggplants can get ya fired or fined for becoming obese and smoking :D

Here's the most outrageous bit:

" Companies are not just doing pre-employment screening for illegal drugs now but all kinds of bad habits and health ailments. A growing list of companies are very open about their strict standards. The Cleveland Clinic has openly admitted that starting September 1st, 2007 if pre-employment screening finds nicotine in a potential employees system they will immediately be denied employment. A company called Clarian Health has sent notifications to it’s large pool of employees letting them know that starting in 2009 employees will be charged $5 per paycheck if they are found using tobacco. The charges don’t end there. Clarian has also stated that if tests show the employee has abnormal levels of cholesterol, blood pressure and a growing list of other tests they will be charged $5 on each paycheck for each occurrence of those criteria."

I happen to know 3 people who are rail thin, eat very healthy yet have high cholesterol.
My husband is very overweight, eats nothing but junk but has great cholesterol numbers.
I don't know mine because I refuse to have it checked.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread