How should the FDA regulate e-cigs?

How Should the FDA Regulate E-Cigs?

  • It should not.

  • Minimal regulations only.

  • Very little regulation.

  • Tobacco-like regulation.

  • Medicines regulation.

  • Ban them.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I've put together a quick poll here: How Should the FDA Regulate E-Cigs? (poll 7636033) | Polldaddy.com

Please vote and share.


A. It should not. Unregulated e-cigs are still vastly safer than the alternative, so let them thrive!

B. Minimal regulations only. Establish manufacturing and labeling standards for e-liquids (such as clean facilities, a minimum purity level, accurate labeling and full ingredient disclosure), but no restrictions on advertising, flavors or nicotine.

C. Very little regulation. Establish manufacturing standards, with some rules on advertising (to prevent marketing to non-smokers or children), flavors (if specific components are shown to be a concern) and nicotine (sufficiently high for mixers, around 75 mg/ml).

D. tobacco-like regulation. Advertisements for e-cigarettes should be heavily restricted, flavors limited to menthol and tobacco (or options available through NRT) and a lower nicotine limit (around 30 mg/ml).
Medicines regulation. Stringent manufacturing and safety guidelines, restrictions on selling locations, strict limitations on flavors and proof of efficacy. Effectively turning e-cigs into a new form of NRT in the eyes of the government.

E. Ban them. They threaten to re-normalize smoking, may serve as a gateway to tobacco use for children, most contain nicotine – a poison – and carcinogens have been detected. People shouldn’t be allowed to reduce the risks of nicotine consumption.
 

WickedSick

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 10, 2011
1,475
992
USA
I think that as far as e-liquids are concerned there must be some kind of regulation. It is something potentially dangerous if someone messes up and mixes something that isn't supposed to be there. There is also need to at least some degree for the advertisement and who is allowed to buy them. But if the the regulations are like the ones in the tobacco industry it will crush most of the companies and eradicate the competition among the different brands.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread