FDA Is this a big part of the problem?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nate760

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 11, 2014
1,301
4,541
San Marcos, CA, USA
DC that's a bit of a swipe, don'tcha think?

For the sake of my own sanity I read in the FDA forum for a bit, push back from the table and throw up, and revisit after I have regained my composure. There is a lot of wouldacouldacan'twon'tdidn'tmaybesortakinda going on in there, with limited practical purpose or application or strategy right now being suggested. Obsessing for the sake of making "forum points" by bloating up those threads with, well, hyperbole while offering little in ideas for practical recourse ain't helping. Reading it all sure isn't changing anything.

More doing points, far less chatting in circles.
:2c:

These are perfectly valid points, but at the same time, I would submit that since there are a number of different ways this could wind up playing out, it behooves us to examine all the plausible scenarios and prepare for them accordingly. While you're correct that some of the arguments being put forward are more hyperbolic than anything else (the most irrational/hysterical of which can and should be dismissed out of hand), I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing that there's such a wide range of interpretations being put forth at this stage.
 

Devonmoonshire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2011
6,750
7,969
San Diego, CA
These are perfectly valid points, but at the same time, I would submit that since there are a number of different ways this could wind up playing out, it behooves us to examine all the plausible scenarios and prepare for them accordingly. While you're correct that some of the arguments being put forward are more hyperbolic than anything else (the most irrational/hysterical of which can and should be dismissed out of hand), I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing that there's such a wide range of interpretations being put forth at this stage.

Your phraseology plays perfectly into what I would like to submit as well......

The shear variety and differences in interpretation of these regulations points to one inescapable conclusion. The FDA is supposed to release these in terms that a layperson can understand clearly and concisely. They have, (Based on the very variety of which I speak in interpretation), Failed to do so. If there is that much "Interpretation" then they cannot have possibly been stated clearly. In which case they are summarily deemed inadequate and invalid.

Just my :2c:
 

SensesFailed

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 14, 2014
118
160
Berwick, PA, USA
This might come off as attacking, but I'm not trying to do that, so I apologize if you become offended by what I have to say. I think part of it is some of us have differing opinions on how to handle things, not everyone is going to immediately jump into signing every petition, posting every chance we get in this forum or in even in some instances, some people might be turned off from really voicing their opinion because if it just happens to go against people, it seems like they are alienated for having a different view.

I'm not saying everyone does it, but I've seen posts that come off like that in different threads. It is what it is, as long as their are people that are doing their research, then when they voice their opinion shouldn't matter whether it is on day 1 or day 65 or the last day.
 

Nate760

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 11, 2014
1,301
4,541
San Marcos, CA, USA
This might come off as attacking, but I'm not trying to do that, so I apologize if you become offended by what I have to say. I think part of it is some of us have differing opinions on how to handle things, not everyone is going to immediately jump into signing every petition, posting every chance we get in this forum or in even in some instances, some people might be turned off from really voicing their opinion because if it just happens to go against people, it seems like they are alienated for having a different view.

I'm not saying everyone does it, but I've seen posts that come off like that in different threads. It is what it is, as long as their are people that are doing their research, then when they voice their opinion shouldn't matter whether it is on day 1 or day 65 or the last day.

I can't imagine why anyone would be offended by what you've said here. I don't disagree with any of it.
 

Devonmoonshire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2011
6,750
7,969
San Diego, CA
I think that the most important factor of all to keep in mind is that regardless of our different views and ideas of how things "Should Be Handled" We All Agree that SOMETHING should be done and are really anxious to see the ball get rolling on it.

I can say this though, this is one damned big ball to get rolling and it is imperative that it be started to roll in the right direction to act as a wrecking ball against the criminal injustices being proposed.
 

Elizabeth Baldwin

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 2, 2014
3,668
5,069
Lexington, Kentucky, United States
I read and post frequently in the FDA threads, but it gets old fast when you see people who seem oblivious to the threat. And they make outlandish and uneducated points like they're trying to convince others that there's nothing to worry about. I hope too many people don't buy into these claims because these are the ones who will do nothing when the time comes to act. They have a false sense of security and are trying to spread it like a virus.

I go to the CASAA site often and check for any updated info as well. I'm anxiously waiting for direction from CASAA. I hope many others are too. I wish vendors would ban together and form a coalition of some sort. Maybe pool some of their money to help CASAA. I know we have resources if everyone would do their part. I just hope all these sleeping giants are waiting on CASAA as well.
 

Nate760

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 11, 2014
1,301
4,541
San Marcos, CA, USA
I think that the most important factor of all to keep in mind is that regardless of our different views and ideas of how things "Should Be Handled" We All Agree that SOMETHING should be done and are really anxious to see the ball get rolling on it.

I can say this though, this is one damned big ball to get rolling and it is imperative that it be started to roll in the right direction to act as a wrecking ball against the criminal injustices being proposed.

As I keep reiterating as often as possible, we must continue to emphasize, in the strongest possible terms, that this issue is merely a microcosm of a much bigger, much more important issue; an issue in which every American has a stake, irrespective of whether they smoke, used to smoke, or never smoked. Under the banner of "public health," our government is pursuing policies that are designed to kill us. And we should be mad as hell about it.
 

SensesFailed

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 14, 2014
118
160
Berwick, PA, USA
I can't imagine why anyone would be offended by what you've said here. I don't disagree with any of it.

You never know, people can take different things different ways, I just wanted to make sure that I wasn't trying to offend anyone, just giving an explanation for why it's possible that some people don't post in this sub-forum.
 

Tealady12

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 12, 2013
134
148
St Paul, MN
Assorted PV Topics (271 Viewing)
General E-Liquid Discussion (263 Viewing)
General E-Smoking Discussion (193 Viewing)
APV Discussion (189 Viewing)
E-Cigarette Suppliers Forum (69 Viewing)
E-Cigarette Reviews (53 Viewing)
Model Specific Discussion (50 Viewing)
Modding Forum (39 Viewing)
Health, Safety, and E-Smoking (37 Viewing)
Ecigarette Technical Issues (35 Viewing)
E-Liquid Reviews (34 Viewing)
Members and Classifieds Swaps (26 Viewing)
Tips and Tricks (25 Viewing)
FDA Regulations (18 Viewing)

I agree and i am very frustrated. I have posted in the general forum a call to join Casaa. I have been putting links on all articles that i come across. I asked on Casaa's Facebook page on April 27th for a total of members it was 12,744. I asked again last night, they are now up to 15,307. This is not enough. Other advocacy groups are looking towards Casaa to lead the way, For this to happen and be successful, there needs to a whole lot more participate. At this point I do not see the FDA getting too much opposition from the people.
 
Jan 19, 2014
1,039
2,370
Moved On
I couldn't agree more. There's just enough stuff in that PDF to fuel the hopes of optimists whose perspective I can only describe as naive and uninformed by the FDA's own history, Zeller's own words (and his own history as a BP lobbyist), as well as the history of the FSPTCA - which is the act under which vaping will be regulated-down-to-cigAlikes, as CASAA's press release already points out:

CASAA: FDA regulation of e-cigarettes: huge costs, little or no benefit, says CASAA

Just because CASAA's press release doesn't scream ALL THAT'S GOING TO BE LEFT IS CIGaLIKES

... doesn't mean that's not the case. You don't even have to read between the lines.

It's right here: "Although the regulations do not openly ban the refillable devices that are preferred by experienced users, they impose a costly registration and approval process that would effectively eliminate them."

Diverse opinions are good in a public forum, as a general matter. But when some folks think that two plus two is three, others think that it's five, and a few more believe that it might be six, or even two ... then "Houston, we have a problem."

Zeller's running around the country giving interviews about this proposed rule, saying that "Tobacco Products" kill 400,000 Americans a year - and yes, he's lumping vaping in with tobacco cigarettes. The purpose of the FSPTCA is primarily to regulate tobacco cigarettes.

Vaping hasn't killed anyone. And it's not goihg to. Quite the opposite.

What else do we need to know? Or should I ask - how naive can some folks get??

You put your finger right on it, Elizabeth ...

I read and post frequently in the FDA threads, but it gets old fast when you see people who seem oblivious to the threat. And they make outlandish and uneducated points like they're trying to convince others that there's nothing to worry about. I hope too many people don't buy into these claims because these are the ones who will do nothing when the time comes to act. They have a false sense of security and are trying to spread it like a virus.

I go to the CASAA site often and check for any updated info as well. I'm anxiously waiting for direction from CASAA. I hope many others are too. I wish vendors would ban together and form a coalition of some sort. Maybe pool some of their money to help CASAA. I know we have resources if everyone would do their part. I just hope all these sleeping giants are waiting on CASAA as well.
 
Last edited:

salemgold

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 5, 2010
28,155
63,784
South Carolina
Assorted PV Topics (271 Viewing)
General E-Liquid Discussion (263 Viewing)
General E-Smoking Discussion (193 Viewing)
APV Discussion (189 Viewing)
E-Cigarette Suppliers Forum (69 Viewing)
E-Cigarette Reviews (53 Viewing)
Model Specific Discussion (50 Viewing)
Modding Forum (39 Viewing)
Health, Safety, and E-Smoking (37 Viewing)
Ecigarette Technical Issues (35 Viewing)
E-Liquid Reviews (34 Viewing)
Members and Classifieds Swaps (26 Viewing)
Tips and Tricks (25 Viewing)
FDA Regulations (18 Viewing)

I have noticed the same myself. Actually to have 18 viewing here is more than what I normally see here :(
 

Devonmoonshire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2011
6,750
7,969
San Diego, CA
As I keep reiterating as often as possible, we must continue to emphasize, in the strongest possible terms, that this issue is merely a microcosm of a much bigger, much more important issue; an issue in which every American has a stake, irrespective of whether they smoke, used to smoke, or never smoked. Under the banner of "public health," our government is pursuing policies that are designed to kill us. And we should be mad as hell about it.

I agree and I am mad as hell about it. It is just plain wrong and as I stated elsewhere the media seems to have dropped this issue all together, I have not seen anything on it on any of the news channels in four days or more.

That could be a good thing or it could be a bad thing. Either way the news is being tight lipped about it right now.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
DC that's a bit of a swipe, don'tcha think?
Well, it's certainly not a swipe at you, because you're here.
:)

But I have to wonder how many of those 1200+ people spend any time in here at all.
When less than 1.5% of the members here are viewing this subforum, I get pretty concerned.
 

Devonmoonshire

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2011
6,750
7,969
San Diego, CA
DC that's a bit of a swipe, don'tcha think?

For the sake of my own sanity I read in the FDA forum for a bit, push back from the table and throw up, and revisit after I have regained my composure. There is a lot of wouldacouldacan'twon'tdidn'tmaybesortakinda going on in there, with limited practical purpose or application of strategy right now being suggested. Obsessing for the sake of making "forum points" by bloating up those threads with, well, hyperbole while offering little in ideas for practical recourse ain't helping. Reading it all sure isn't changing anything.

More doing points, far less chatting in circles.
:2c:

I can't see it as so much of a "Swipe" as more of a challenge to really stay tuned and keep active in the future of the Vaping community. Sounds more like a challenge to be involved to me than anything else :D

I do get tired though of seeing some folks argue for the sake of arguing. I may not agree with everyone's perspective and opinion on the issue, but I do try to present my opinion on it in a manor that does not directly attack someone else's opinion on the matter. I might not agree with someone but I will not say outright that they are wrong and my opinion is the only one that is right. Some folks have taken it to that level and it is unacceptable behavior to me since we are all in essence fighting for the same thing.... Our Right to Save Our Own lives with these devices.
 

progg

Account closed on request
ECF Veteran
Apr 17, 2010
1,760
2,249
It is a part of the problem.

There's others. From my perspective :

People who hold the presumption of liberty as a perspective are represented within the various FDA threads but the majority of the FDA opposition at ECF (as far as I can tell) holds the view, implicitly or explicitly, that govt, via the FDA, holds the ultimate 'solution'. "We must face the reality that reasonable regulation is inevitable." And for many at ECF, I think, desirable.


An example of this is fluid packaging and labeling. It's been a recurrent issue here and usually it's had an accusatory finger pointed towards vendors. "It's the vendors own fault if the FDA slams the hammer down upon them. They should have organized and set standards long ago." That view omits the many good things vendors have accomplished in supplying us vapers with product and ignores the prospect (from a vendors perspective) of losing to govt seizure the investment of time and money towards fulfilling that market segment. In this sense, and others, prospective govt regulation via the FDA has been ......ing and distorting vaping's marketplace.

I don't have any idea how to directly fight those who we are now facing. They are unelected, insulated, and some are evidently willing and able to lie as their needs require. True evil. The ends justify the means. (I'm sure there are some decent people there and to them I say -- stand up now and say 'enough'. Be someone who doesn't just go along. Be that someone(s) that goes down in history as standing for individual Human rights. I would gladly work towards you retaining your govt employment in some capacity if you'd expose the fallacy, that is, that any central agency can morally effect individual human exchange. The law of unintended consequences is undeniable. A dying cancer patient cannot use experimentals. Really? Someone finds pleasure from vaping or possibly even saves their life because they replaced their cigarette habit with vaping and you want to in effect destroy that industry and destroy the potentialities of same. Really? Stand up and ask -- "By what right do we cruelly burden our fellow citizens?".)

Although Congress has in a cowardly fashion given up (I think unconstitutionally) much of its power via agencies and the like, and sadly, it must be noted at the behest and/or acquiescence of voters, ultimately that's where the fight for vaping liberty lies. They can create law that supersedes regulatory law. It is politics. And it is within every citizen's ability to decide what type of country they want. For vaping as we know it, it just might be too late. Hope I'm wrong. But for the country long term, it's imperative that the capital d discussion centers on individual liberty. Although liberty isn't always pretty is this ? A-Z Index of U.S. Government Departments and Agencies (A) | USA.gov Is it possible for any citizen to not unintentionally violate some statute somewhere created by someone(s) who wanted their idea of 'good' to come from your hide, your paycheck, your life?

To those who have tried, despite the replies which have attempted to minimize your comments via logical fallacies such as -- "Surely you don't believe that extremist position!"-- , to move people towards the presumption of liberty, thank you. I admire your efforts. I can't come here often anymore due to life's circumstance but when I do it's uplifting to read your 'extremist' attempts to convince people to live their lives as a person should -- as a proud, free human. An American.

To those who can't be bothered with politics or actively pooh, pooh, liberty pushers -- How's the reasonableness from the FDA look so far? Doesn't really matter how reasonable it is though ,does it. They decide what reasonable is and they'll dang well use every means available to them, including police power, to make you 'see the light' of their reasonableness. A little compromise here, a little head in the sand there -- nice recipe for sheep stew, eh?

To DC2 -- if my post has offended the intention of your thread, I sincerely apologize and understandably expect its removal .

To SJ -- Again, I appreciate the forum you've created. An American spouting off about Liberty in a Brit's house, who would've thunk it. :facepalm: Thank you.
 

badwolf91

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 13, 2014
117
106
Iowa
in regards to the post about age being a deciding factor in the group here fighting for rights, I have emailed 50 iowa senators and every legislator possible even before the FDA legs came out. I am 23, and after 5+ years of smoking was able to finally quit after a few attempts with the gum and that crap that did not work. I think it is a mixture of concerned people of various ages, just ones who have seen and are interested in the history and the future of this country and mankind itself. I do not watch reality shows about some persons lame life, I read and watch historical documents hoping to learn more about what we have done so we do not repeat it and expand my knowledge of mankind as it seems to be a constant circle of repetition throughout history just in slightly different manners but the same "backbone" per say. Many people this age need help seeing as they have seemingly just lost hope in the system and think that no matter what they do it will not matter, this type of thinking is going to throw us down the drain and every person needs to stand up as I have been trying to rally everybody I know and arm them with knowledge. People should never feel like they have no control or that they are in the gov't or big corporations hands, the only way to get out of it is to stand up. This gov't is supposed to be for the people, but if the people don't care or pay attention they can do whatever they please. I see so many people older than me, in their early 30s+ who just don't give a darn what is happening and couldn't care less. For them, it doesn't matter until it directly affects them and by then it is too late, either way they will just complain a little about how "oh that's just wrong" and get on with their day, we all have to band together for each other to actually be free and the lack of this is so sad to see my fellow countrymen just submitting to any rule imposed even if they disagree, they just submit. The further they restrict us I do see more people trying to stand up for freedom which is in the end what will save us all from a completely controlling gov't that we are falling into. I pray it will not be to late as noted there are too many who just don't care until it slaps them in the face :(

Vape on, and never give up! We are all in the same boat no matter who we are or what background/age we come from/are. Some of us will never submit and will never allow freedom to die as too many people have died for this great cause that is being slowly undermined. I will never forget those who have died for us, even if I don't know them personally they were still our family as Americans and could easily have been you or someone close to you. As noted we need to spread the word across all forums if possible/ecf rules comply once we have a call to action from CASAA to give these people that don't know or understand an idea of whats happening and what they can do. These regulations are still so new that a lot probably did not know they were coming so are still in the dark as they are not seeking out the knowledge of gov't activity. We need to get them in the light, rally the troops as one said before me once we have a backbone to our strategy that some of you guys help build as there are some very intelligent people here that can help lead, and that is what you must do if you have the knowledge. I am inspired by how many great, critical thinkers I have met on ECF. A unified front will be everything and we don't want everyone running around like chickens missing heads. We do have the ability to change this country and we need to use it as a whole. We just need Americans to work together not against eachother, even on the road you see people who don't care about you they will cut you off and expect you to yield for them when they would never do the same. There is too much hate for no reason when we need to find a way to unify the American people as a whole, I just have not found of a way with how the media pushes us all in different directions and not many will go beyond seeking out the information that their local news tells them.

sorry long post, I have a problem with that when it comes to rights and freedom...hope it was worth the read. Maybe we really can find a way to get people all across the states (even the world) on the same page, care for one another's liberty. seeking out knowledge is key, and history is a great start to understand why and where we are now. I just want it known that there are those of us that are not in the older age category that care very dearly about America's future and every persons freedom.
 

badwolf91

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 13, 2014
117
106
Iowa
thanks, I do notice that even though I cannot see how many people are viewing the fda rules forum area for some reason like the poster is, that many of these threads do have 1000's of views which could helpfully show that people are looking and then moving on as suggested instead of being glued to this area of the forum (like I am :p ), trying to stay in the loop but also continue to actively manage other areas of the forum. That makes me somewhat optimistic, though some of them could probably be the same person viewing more than once.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread