I received a 12mg bottle of this juice from the last IVape contest. When given the choice of flavors to choose, I went with the Sweet Caroline as I had heard so many people speak highly of it. First off the juice is not very thick and is not dark and cloudy. Is this an indication of quality? I honestly don't have a clue. I'm new to vaping, and find myself many times satisfied with Chinese Marl flavor. I have been using the Sweet Caroline for about 2 weeks now. It seems that when I open the bottle I can really smell the juice, did not notice this when I first got it. There is definately a sweet edge to the flavor. I like having a nice tobacco flavor in the morning, a throw back to the old rise and shine days with a coffee and a smoke. I have to be honest, I find it hard to describe in words the flavor and scent of this juice. Its a different kind of sweetness, it's not sweet like a candy, not sugary. Not fruity. Almost kind of like a liquor maybe. The scent seems familiar but it really escapes me as to what is so familiar about it. It is nice and smooth, and I find it enjoyable. It is a nice change from the more straight forward traditional tobacco flavor. I find myself using it daily and will most likey order more. Just my opinion is all, YMMV.