It's taken me a while but I am realizing that I am just not a tobacco flavor person. I've been sampling plain menthol and they are all pretty good. The best so far has been a simple DIY with menthol drops. It's a good TH even at 12mg. I've tried both 100% PG and an 80/20 mix. You can add a drop or 2 of spearmint, peppermint or vanilla if the mood strikes you.