New Study: Doubling of Mean Reduction in Cigarette Consumption Among Ecig users

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bill Godshall

Executive Director<br/> Smokefree Pennsylvania
ECF Veteran
Apr 2, 2009
5,171
13,288
67
While the O'Connor et al survey/study reported some positive findings about e-cigarette use, the study also failed to cite and/or show some potentially critically important data.

For example, the study's authors stated 11% of ENDS users had quit smoking, and that it was similar to the percentage of non ENDS users who had quit smoking. But virtually no ENDS users (perhaps 1 and no more than 2) were classified as "long term quitters", while a far greater number and percentage (neither of which was revealed by the authors) of "long term quitters" had never tried ENDS and weren't current users of ENDS.

Thus, its likely that "long term quitters" accounted for most (or virtually all) of the approximately 11% of the non ENDS users who the authors claimed had quit smoking. On other words, had "long term quitters" (virtually none of whom reported any use of e-cigs) been excluded from this study, the 11% of ENDS users who quit smoking would have been greater (and perhaps 2, 3, 4 or more times greater) than the percentage of non ENDS users who reported quitting smoking.
 

Bill Godshall

Executive Director<br/> Smokefree Pennsylvania
ECF Veteran
Apr 2, 2009
5,171
13,288
67
And since virtually all "long term quitters" reported never using an ENDS, "long term quitters" likely accounted for most of the 2 cigs/day cigarette consumption decline among non ENDS users.

Thus, the authors stated finding that ENDS users reduced average cigarette consumption by twice as much as non ENDS users (4 cigs/day compared to 2 cigs/day) was also probably deceptive, as the decline in cigarette consumption by ENDS users (i.e. 4 cigs/day) was likely 3, 4, 5 or more times greater than the cigarette consumption decline among non ENDS users who weren't "long term quitters".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread