Performance matters more than flavor... remembering Vapenstein's addo scienta

Status
Not open for further replies.

lasttango

What would Freud say?
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 10, 2010
4,067
2,286
Wilmington, DE / Ithaca, NY
www.last.fm
I am vaping Goodejuice's Ice Cold Menthol at the moment.

It has almost zero flavor.

It does produce a ton of "sensation."

It has a very satisfying throat hit, burns clean in my carto and produces tons of vapor. (18mg... 50/50). @ 5volts with a 3.0 ohm Ikenvape 801 fusion carto.

No aftertaste whatsoever...outside of the icy cooling menthol sensation.

I am on day 4 with the same carto... and there's no drop in the cartos performance...

Flavor is great, but I think in our elusive quest to find the best tasting or most authentic tasting juice, we often forget about performance... or we sacrifice it -

If sweet and tasty foods make us fat... then sweet and tasty vapes often kill cartos and create hardware frustration.

I believe it's time to make "performance" part of the conversation again.

So, I copied and am pasting a segment of Dr. V's long and informative and entertaining reflection on juices...

Screw it, let's start with a clean slate

The most overlooked aspect of making juice is performance.

Broken down to the most basic set of criteria, we need to provide an experience that will satisfy the recent ex-smoker. As good as some of the newer artificially flavored juices are, a Camel smoker is not going to jump the fence for Blackberry Lemonade Menthol. Maybe 6 months down the road, but for now we have to help them fool their brain so they can kick tobacco and stay off.

Forget about all the approaches. That's the repertoire you'll pull from to make your juice, but you need to concentrate on the basics. Two words. Performance and flavor.

Clean burning juice that provides satisfying throat hit is crucial. You have to feel like you're vaping something of substance, otherwise it's just eating a bag of Doritos to keep from smoking a cigarette and you're still thinking about that cigarette. All the time. You can not underestimate the importance of performance in your juice. Clean burning, because juice that is hard on attys means your atty is going to produce its best output for a very short amount of time, and then the vaper is stuck getting only a percentage of their juice's flavor and impact. I am very careful about how frequently I vape juice that doesn't burn well, and I really, really appreciate juice that doesn't make me have to think about it.

Throat hit. The law of diminishing returns kicks in quick, but smoking was like that too. If you chain smoke your cigarette doesn't have much impact, but if you haven't smoked one in 4 hours it's like sex. Nicotine plays a big role in that, but so does throat hit. I absolutely need awesome throat hit to keep me satisfied and I doubt that will ever change.

Good quality, pure PG plays a huge role in this. If your nic base turns yellow after a few weeks, you're using insecticide. Start over. Juices that significantly darken as they sit are made using subpar base. Good base stays clear. PG allergies aside, PG is the primary suspension agent in asthma inhalers. Don't worry about vaping it if you're tolerant. I have far more concerns about VG being a vegetable fat than I have about PG, which is in everything from commercial tobacco to candy to medicine.

Nicotine of course, but a vaper should stick with the nic level their body needs and not try to compensate for poor performing juice by overdosing themselves on nicotine to get more throat hit.

PGA. Hmm. I always said that I didn't trust someone who added PGA to their juice for added throat hit. I think I am going to reverse my position on that. One vendor I really like has juice that burns so clean I swear that it cleans attys. It must have added PGA, it just must. I happen to think that juice is really satisfying too, so don't rule out a light handed application of PGA.

Flavorings play a role in throat hit, but you're at the mercy of the flavorings used whether or not they will be a performance factor.

Lastly, we need a flavor that helps people make the jump, whether that means a natural tobacco or something that fools the brain into thinking tobacco. Whatever works. The really good ones capture some aspect that helps the illusion. A smoky exhale, a dry inhale with great throat hit, anything that helps people forget they aren't smoking anymore. Method doesn't matter here, it's about the end result.

What makes a successful vaper is performance. If the performance is there, people won't stray back to cigarettes. It's the elusive target of making juice that scratches the itch. Throat hit, flavor, that feeling of satisfaction in your chest when you inhale the vapor. The needs of the new vaper are quite different than the needs of the veteran. Apple pie ala mode with great throat hit will work once you've been vaping for a while, but the new vaper is too close to their last cigarette to accept something so alien when their brain is craving and expecting something so different.



spelling error in title, I know... addo scientia


entire post: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...scussion/206373-vapenstein-addo-scientia.html
 
Last edited:

samuraijill

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 28, 2011
824
1,496
Oregon High Desert
This was a great and informative read. As an example, I switched over from BWB malty toffee to just malty because it starts clear, stays clear and is much easier on equipment- to speak back to the post it doesn't make me think about it constantly where MT was a constant struggle.
I am curious to know how to find vendors who use a 'purer' base; I recently cleaned out and tossed a bunch of old juices from the vendor I order from most frequently and they were almost all the color of black coffee, blech. Is there a thread somewhere that has covered this?
 

lasttango

What would Freud say?
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 10, 2010
4,067
2,286
Wilmington, DE / Ithaca, NY
www.last.fm
pure bases... Many vendors who by through Levi at Xtremevaping have superior bases...

I heard Levi will take a batch back if the vendor ever complains about it - or even if the weather effects it... levi apparently cares about providing superior nic and base...

bwb, want2vape, goodejuice, ahlusion,,, certainly the lab juices do... like halo, TW... nHaler octane
 

Jerms

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2011
9,252
25,832
Fargo
Ahhhh performance. It's funny, Dr V talked about it's importance but also had in hand in making some of the worst performing NETs out there lol. I don't consider performance much, but I appreciate a good performing juice and definately notice a bad performing one.

There's a couple aspects of performance that are important to consider. A big one is how gunk prone it is. That's a big deal if after a few vapes the quality of vapes suffer. Type of atomizing device plays a role, but they all come down to having a coil that heats up juice it makes contact with. When that coil develops gunk on it, it won't perform as well as should. Cartos are huge when it comes to clean juices, as the filler collects all those particulates in a dirty juice which effects wicking, and nothing can be done to clean off a dirty coil. When I used cartos on the go, clear menthols/mints gave the best performance. Atomizers, rebuildables, and many clearos can be dry-burned, but who wants to do that all the time. The flavorings used, level of sweetness, and particulate matter all effect how clean a juice vapes. Some say vg gunks quicker than pg, I'm not so sure.

Throat hit is another important aspect in performance, as Dr V also mentioned. There NEEDs to be TH for me to enjoy a juice. The type of atomizing device effects this too, but that being equal it's all about nicotine. Nicotine provides the TH, pg as a base allows it to come through the best, and vg can soften the TH. If I order a juice in a 50/50 ratio at my normal 18mg and there's no TH, the vendor is doing something wrong. Some vendors provide all VG juices with good TH (like AVE and Ahlusion), and I don't know how they do it when with others the VG level plays a bigger part. If a vendor sells all VG juice with much less TH, I order higher nic next time, but I love it when a vendor makes juices that the TH comes through at any ratio.

Then there's vapor. I never understood reviews that talked about how much vapor a juice produces. Vapor is controlled by atomizing divice, heat provided, and pg/vg ratio. More vg more vapor. The only reason to note vapor production with a juice is if it doesn't PERFORM like it should. That happened to me once with a juice from Virgin Vapor. It was almost black with poor flavor, but at 100% vg I expected big vapor, but the vapor production was poorer than high pg juices. How they made an all vg juice with poor vapor production baffled me.

I kind of take performance for granted, maybe because I just expect a juice to perform well. Most of them do, but when they don't it's very disappointing. I'm fairly forgiving, since I mainly vape NETs which are more gunk prone by nature, and use rebuildable drippers that do great with dirty juices. If a juice gunks things up really quick, doesn't provide proper TH at the nic level, or doesn't provide the vapor it should at a given ratio, I considered it a failed juice and won't order it again.

Sent from my LGL55C using Tapatalk 2
 

Mr.Mann

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 30, 2011
17,401
40,572
47
All over the place
I am a recent convert to seeking out performance.

Ahhhh performance. It's funny, Dr V talked about it's importance but also had in hand in making some of the worst performing NETs out there lol.

Jerms, you're a riot.

More vg more vapor.

Like you said though, all things equal (same set-up), not all 100% VG juices perform as they should. I am constantly baffled, amazed and thrilled at the high PG percentage in Halo and it still delivers a consistent and plentiful vapor output. But then, as you said, there are those all VG juices that give great TH--yeah, it's all about who is making the juice as opposed to the standard facts of the juice's make-up.
 
Last edited:

Jerms

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2011
9,252
25,832
Fargo
I have completely missed the boat on rebuildable atomizers. I don't even know where to start.
I think a person like myself who emphasizes "performance" should be somewhat adept at rba's...

where do I start? anyone know?

Remember DonDaBoom's (whatever happened to that guy?) vaping guide? It was so thorough yet easy to understand for newbies. That helped me so much when I started. There's a need for someone to do just as good a job on a guide for RBAs.

Rebuilding is not hard, nor requires a degree of talent, there's just so much info to take in, so many options and variables (and so many opinions on the "best" way to do things). When I was first interested I went to the RA section here at ECF, and it was like when I started here, I really didn't understand what people were talking about. May as well have been speaking another language. I started a thread there saying what I think I was looking for (mainly dripper, not tank) and they guided me.

So that's my advice on where to start, make a thread in the RA section asking for help and read through threads there.

Sent from my LGL55C using Tapatalk 2
 

jefsview

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
May 2, 2013
9,756
11,127
Crete, Il
As well as Jerms' excellent suggestion, many of the Youtube Videos from Pbusardo and even GrimmGreen have some great learning from the beginning guides of simple to more complex RBA/RDA's from the small, easy ones to the harder Genesis style ones. Todd Ecigreviews is great for that as well, and all of them sometimes fail before your eyes, or make a mess of it... And it's all about learning. We all have to, if we want to :)

I'm certain there are better ones out there as well, but these guys keep it real and are humorous in their approach, keeping it real and accessible.

By watching them, I'm willing to give it a try myself. And some of these are under $10... which is new to me :oops:

But, performance is important. I just got upset that one of my dual coil Iclears got gunked on a new coil with HHV NETs. The coils were fused together with gunk after 1 tankful. Don't know what happened, but it wasted another 3ml of juice before I discovered it. I must have moved the coils together after the cleaning between flavors and ruined it. My fault, not the juices.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread