Singers who vape?

Status
Not open for further replies.

oxygen thief

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 26, 2012
1,067
1,383
Hubby and I are both musicians who quit smoking and started vaping just over 4 months ago. I barely do a little backup vocals, but hubby is an awesome lead singer.

He told me that he has noticed a definite increase in his vocal range since he quit smoking, but he is having more trouble with vocal control. We suspect this is due to the PG drying out the mucus membranes, but if so, what can be done about it (other than not vaping, which he really doesn't want to do)?

I wondered about going to 100% VG (or close to it), but I'm not aware of a tank and stock coils that handle this very well, and dripping during a gig is not an option.

I also wondered if there is a drink / lozenge / medication / something that can maybe coat his throat to prevent the drying effect.

Surely there are other singers here who have dealt with this and found something that helps?

A singer in a band I was in had lots of throat issues. I found some throat lozenges, don't recall the name, that took care of his problem. They aren't OTC but are sold from the pharmacy without a script. You'll just have to ask a pharmacist.
 

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
Update:

He played a gig last night. I haven't had time to buy any sprays yet, but he started hydrating well before the gig, and during the gig. And paying closer attention to what is happening. This is what he told me :

It seems like the vocal control issues are mostly in his lower register. He is now realizing that his range is greater, but all of the range he's gained is on the higher end. The low end of his register has suffered - he said he struggled with vocal control on the low end. Short term fix - he just shifted up a key or two on some of his songs.

This still may have something to do with dehydration, but after this updated info, I am starting to think about the tobacco. He was a heavy smoker - 2 or more packs a day. Even though we rolled our own using a decent quality tobacco (Daughters & Ryan, not any of that cheap crap they sell in tobacco stores) there may have been something in the tobacco that "loosened" his vocal cords? So I am still thinking about a spray or lozenge - I'll probably get some of the Singer's Saving Grace.

Thanks again for all the info and support - ECF rocks!! And since there are so many singers here, I will continue to update with anything else I learn, and hope you guys will do the same.
 

Johntodd

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 18, 2011
676
833
USA
Good to hear.

But I gotta tell you: The smoke was causing inflammation. The inflammation changed the shape of his vocal folds, airways, lungs, etc.

By removing the smoke, he's removing the inflammation.

That means that his vocal "equipment" is changing shape all over. So it's going to be like getting a throat transplant. And a larynx transplant. And double lung transplants.

It's like having to sing through someone else's throat. There are similarities, but also differences.

What I had to do was some training exercises. You mentioned a lack of control: that was the tip-off for me. Simple Me-May-Mi-Mo-Moo exercises descending down the scale, along with Do-Mi-Dos (I and V of the scale) helped me a lot. All that fundamental stuff new singers have to do to get control has to be done again when you quit smoking.

But it's not a complete do-over. His years of experience will REALLY make his progress go much, much faster. It's all a matter of doing some exercises to learn to control his "new gear", rather than learning to sing from scratch.

As for irritation, it's a matter of hydration and coating, like so many others have suggested. His throat may also be tender from the healing that is happening. Maybe a two-week vacation away from singing is in order? If he can do that? A 2-week investment in healing now will pay big dividends for the rest of his singing life.

Hope this helps!
-Johntodd
 

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
It's like having to sing through someone else's throat.
That's similar to what he told me -- he said his vocal cords "feel different". So he is now learning to use his "new" vocal cords.

After his gig last night, he is still concerned about the lower register, but overall he is happy with the improvement in his range and lung capacity, so vaping has been a good thing!! He'll just have to work on the low end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johntodd

Shipwreck

Senior Member
Jun 4, 2015
263
353
59
Ontario, Canada
Update:

It seems like the vocal control issues are mostly in his lower register. He is now realizing that his range is greater, but all of the range he's gained is on the higher end. The low end of his register has suffered - he said he struggled with vocal control on the low end. Short term fix - he just shifted up a key or two on some of his songs.

Hmmm that's very interesting.... I never even thought of that. When smoking I was forced to bring my register down some, so when I realized my vocals were getting better after quitting smoking I have been concentrating on getting back into the higher registers I couldn't due to the smoking... I haven't tried anything in the lower registers yet... Thanks for mentioning that @KattMamma I'm going to check this out and see if it's the same for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KattMamma

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
You could always consider going close to 100vg if you are to dilute your more viscous juices with distilled water they can wick acceptable in most cartos/clearos, I've been using this method for some time now as I prefer more high VG easy throat hits
Yeah that was one thing I threw at him - he threw it back lol. Wasn't crazy about watering down his juice (what's the opposite of a "super taster"? that's what he is - he needs every drop of flavor), and dripping is out of the question, so... *sigh*
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shipwreck

Iffy

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 3, 2011
9,626
79,411
Florida Suncoast
OK, I'm lil' late to da gig. Had a young lovey v-vert that sang in a 'weekend' band. After three weeks vaping, she had gained half an octave on her upper vocal register. She said her delivery required less effort. She also had to sip water 'tween each song.

Just fer da record, vaping has not aided my voice whatsoever; I can just talk longer without coughing...
toothy.gif
 

KattMamma

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 10, 2015
1,733
6,442
DFW Area, Texas
There is a spray that you can find at music stores and online that may be helpful. It's called "Clear Voice" and comes in small 1 oz. spray pump bottles. Available in different flavors (all bad), but my wife swears by it and it is used by many of the Southern Gospel quartets in the area.
contains glycerine.. maybe he can vape it lol JUST KIDDING!!

I'm not sure what that list of herbs is supposed to do, but I will follow up on it. I always prefer herbal remedies over pharmaceutical ones, if they work, so I'll mention this to hubster as well!

Thanks Zipslack!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread