The Gas Station Argument

Status
Not open for further replies.

MrsCasey

Pink Spot Fanatic
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 23, 2011
7,465
7,265
Long Beach, CA
Why would that cause a rational person to have a negative opinion? It wouldn't.

And I refuse to live my life catering to the irrational. That's a ride that just never ends....

Well, I'm not sure that ecigs are safe to use at the pump so I don't use them there. So i guess that makes me irrational. Even if I did feel they were safe I would not vape at the pump out of courtesy. We need to pick the battles that are really important and I can refrain from vaping for 5 minutes so I will save my energy for a different battle.
 

pumasforpets

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 19, 2012
518
758
NWI
Well, yeah, it's simple. Just can't think of one single reason to specifically avoid it.

I can think of 2...and neither has to do with public perception. 1. Heating element. Keeping ignition sources away from explosive fumes is a good idea. 2. Electricity. There were thoughts that cell phones were causing fires at gas pumps...turns out it was static electricity from peoples' clothes. Either way, it's not a bad plan to keep a device with open electrical contacts that could potentially bridge away from gasoline vapors.

Now I'm specifically talking about using your PV at the pump. I set the auto pump switch and walk 20 feet away to vape. Close enough to quickly reach the pump should it overflow but far enough away to put many cubic meters of air space between myself and the fuel source. You can notably smell gasoline concentrations long before it reaches the LEL (lower explosive limit).
 

ChaosTheory

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 9, 2012
191
133
42
Baltimore
www.epicdelusion.com
I actually find it quite fascinating that people are so overly conscious of risk that they invent these Final Destination type scenarios in their mind and really attempt to apply it to reality.. I mean, really really try to find a way to make it seem like it's equivalent to real harm factors. It's absurd that this even got into whether it is safe to vape at a gas station or not.. since it wasn't the point.

We have become a nation of nitpickers
 

Myriad Dark

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 8, 2011
132
60
Las Vegas
Well, yeah, it's simple. Just can't think of one single reason to specifically avoid it.

The reason I don't vape at the pump is because I find aroma to be a big part of vapeing for me and gas stations always seem to have that "gas station funk" smell to them. If that wasn't an issue I'm sure I'd be gassing up with my Roughstack dangling from my teeth.

I'm on board with everyone that has pointed out the actual properties and combustion parameters of gasoline. Under most circumstances a person would find themselves in when filling up with gas, it is just this side of impossible to cause an explosion with a cigarette, mobile phone or a PV. A person would be far more likely to cause a spark ignited explosion just existing next to their car as they gas up in some place like, oh, let's say a desert such as Las Vegas. I experience static discharges on a regular basis out here and can't recall the last time I heard about a gas station exploding.
 

nanovapr

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 15, 2011
1,013
727
Catatonic State, USA
127.0.0.1
[snip]
subliminalurge, your post made me laugh.
[/snop]

I should have specified this more clearly. I was laughing along with you, because I know what you mean, on liquid gas. Guess I should have said LOL. When I was young, we once drained a metal 5 gallon gas can by riddling it with bullets. Not one generated enough spark to even light it. We should have probably used an empty one. It was an isolated area, private property, 50 yards away, we were being safe.

Still, I've seen enough freak accidents to not risk them now.
 
Last edited:

subliminalurge

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 30, 2011
139
64
Quad Cities
1. Heating element.
2. Electricity.

There are much more powerful sources of both heat and electricity underneath the hood of your car.

The cell phone thing is nothing but a silly internet hoax that too many people took seriously. People have tried experimentally to ignite gasoline with a cell phone and nobody's been able to do it yet. These are people that specifically set out to create fire through any means they could imagine, and they failed. The cell phone thing is just an email hoax that got forwarded all over creation by a whole lot of gullible schmucks. Parroting it around all these years later is not an enhancement to ones credibility.

It is technically possible to ignite gasoline with a cigarette, although it's so incredibly unlikely as to not be worth worrying about. It takes very specific conditions, and you have to actually be trying to create fire.

Starting a fire with a PV? Yes, there is electricity and heat. Both of these are enclosed inside a nice protective metal enclosure (just like all of the much more powerful sources of electricity and heat underneath the hood of your car).

Do you refuse to go home after work and spend the night at the office on a rainy day for fear that you'll get struck by lightning walking to your car? THAT is a much more realistic and rational fear than anything being discussed in this thread.

The stuff being talked about here is BEYOND silliness.
 
Last edited:

ChaosTheory

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 9, 2012
191
133
42
Baltimore
www.epicdelusion.com
Did you know you can start a fire at a gas pump with an ecig? some dude told me on the way to his car before he died after mixing his soda and a bag of pop rocks candy he got from the same gas station.. poor ....... went through all that trouble not vaping at the pump just to die from mixing candy and soda... his stomach just burst into foam... like instantly.. horrible way to go I hear.
 

iamtopher34

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 26, 2010
228
66
43
Sandy Utah
Not vaping while you get gas is no big deal. The issue is people get worked up over the unknown so instead of trying to educate them selfs they will just ban it. And yes i can see this happening but to ban something for fear of someone doing something with it that made someone nervous is just stupid its kinda like outlawing a religion or race that is different from the norm because little old grandmas are afraid of them.

Lighting gas with a cig is soooooooooo hard to do i have tried a lot and never got it to work
 

pumasforpets

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 19, 2012
518
758
NWI
There are much more powerful sources of both heat and electricity underneath the hood of your car.

The cell phone thing is nothing but a silly internet hoax that too many people took seriously. People have tried experimentally to ignite gasoline with a cell phone and nobody's been able to do it yet. These are people that specifically set out to create fire through any means they could imagine, and they failed. The cell phone thing is just an email hoax that got forwarded all over creation by a whole lot of gullible schmucks. Parroting it around all these years later is not an enhancement to ones credibility.

It is technically possible to ignite gasoline with a cigarette, although it's so incredibly unlikely as to not be worth worrying about. It takes very specific conditions, and you have to actually be trying to create fire.

Starting a fire with a PV? Yes, there is electricity and heat. Both of these are enclosed inside a nice protective metal enclosure (just like all of the much more powerful sources of electricity and heat underneath the hood of your car).

Do you refuse to go home after work and spend the night at the office on a rainy day for fear that you'll get struck by lightning walking to your car? THAT is a much more realistic and rational fear than anything being discussed in this thread.

The stuff being talked about here is BEYOND silliness.

Unless your fill spout is IN the engine compartment, you're not going to get enough concentration to reach LEL that far away. The cubic meters of air space increases exponentially the farther you get from the source. Think of the air between you and the source as a cone. If you are .5 meters away from the source, the air space that has to be filled to 1.4% concentration of gasoline vapors is about 1.5 cubic meters. If you are 5 meters away, that volume increases to about 157 cubic meters. Moving a mere 16 feet from the pump increases the amount of gasoline vapor that would have to bleed off from the source by over 100 times. That's the difference I'm talking about between standing at the pump versus standing by the front bumper. For the vapor concentration to reach LEL at 5 meters, it would almost literally knock you out at .5 the concentration at that point would be so high. Funny enough, LEL at 5 meters would almost certainly be above UEL meaning the concentration would be so high that there's not enough oxygen for ignition to happen.

Which is why, if you bothered to read, I stated that it was not cell phones causing the fires, but rather static electricity bridging between 2 conductors. I stated that because, on many e-cigs, there are exposed electrical contacts of questionable quality. Any point where electricity can bridge a gap is a potential ignition source...and as I stated, this includes your own skin to a ground. I personally ground out prior to lifting the pump. Perhaps a little overly cautious, but I worked in the environmental remediation field for a number of years and have seen what happens when un-grounded electronic devices are around gasoline vapors when they reach LEL. Looks really cool...scary as all hell. Have you ever seen a 10,000 gallon steel underground storage tank dance? I have. The tank wasn't completely empty and had not yet been properly ventilated when the vapors reached LEL and ignited. The heat from the ignition vaporized more gas from the tank and kept the cycle going for a good 30 seconds with this 15 ton tank tap dancing.

I've stood at UST pits, vent lines and product lines with an LEL meter and I can tell you for a fact, gasoline reaching its LEL directly at a gas pump is FAR more likely than a lightning strike. At that point, all it takes is an ignition source. As I stated, there are 2 on a PV. The likelihood of ignition from any source it relatively low with modern pump venting designs, I will give you that, but all it takes to make 100 times difference is to move from touching the pump to the front bumper.

We're seriously arguing about walking 5 steps away from the pump while vaping. :blink: To me, taking a mere 5 steps and in doing so lowering my risk by an additional 100 times (on an already fairly low number) is pretty simple math.
 
Last edited:

nanovapr

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 15, 2011
1,013
727
Catatonic State, USA
127.0.0.1
And to go to the opposite extreme? I saw an old mechanic braze a gas tank from a car with a torch. It was an otherwise solid (not rusted) tank that had hit something and punctured. It was an old, odd-shaped tank and replacement wasn't easy.

It was off the car, he filled it full of water to displace the oxygen/vapor. He couldn't seal it tight because of the expansion, he taped the filler neck with duct tape, with holes poked in it. The holes let out water as it expanded. It was scary, I watched from outside the building.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread