UNICORN MILK by Cuttwood

Status
Not open for further replies.

AnnieP65

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 31, 2013
726
2,097
PA, USA
Millis Scientific in Maryland list a price of $20 per sample, don't know if that is just one sample or what but some. Some other labs are like $50 a sample up to $80 an hour.

Good timing!! That's not bad at all! I could pay that. I'll give them a call tomorrow afternoon after work and after I get my strawberry Quik and milk. I'll ask them if I have to specify what chemical, etc., that we're looking for. Thank you!!
 

dubbya

Full Member
Verified Member
Jun 8, 2013
37
20
Charlotte, NC, USA
Yup, I saw that too but since we're not dealing with high enough temperatures (yet) to melt the Kanthal I back-burnered it. Not to be totally overlooked though...

Dry burning a very low resistance coil for cleaning gets really very hot. While it isn't molten hot, it's hotter than I want to get it with this listed in the msds.
 

SharonMM

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 22, 2013
1,477
4,957
Lakeville, MN
You know... This whole situation is just sad for everyone. People want to crucify the maker, which I understand- the guy made a BIG mistake using that ingredient, but I don't think he did it with any intention of malice. He used a food coloring that said on the bottle that it was safe for human consumption. So to the best of his limited knowledge, he was using a safe product. Also, the toxicology of Titanium Dioxide is much less than what we experienced as smokers.. not that this gives him a right to use it or hide the fact that he uses it... Just saying, its very unlikely that anyone will experience any adverse health effects from vaping this in the short term. This is not much different than the diacetyl argument, which many people are aware its in their juice and choose to vape it anyways.

However- It needs to be their choice. I would like to see the maker of Cuttwood publicly admit to his folly and try to make amends. Not addressing the accusation is only adding fuel to the fire. Clearly.

I feel bad for the people who bought this and feel betrayed because it wasn't disclosed. I feel bad for the vendors who are going to take a loss on this, although I do think they should have been more responsible and had the liquids they're selling have a GC/MS analysis done beforehand. Or require the maker to have one done. But since its an unregulated industry, none of this is a requirement. Still, its the right thing to do and could've totally avoided this problem.

I especially feel bad for the vaping community as a whole. Every vendor seems more suspect now, in light of this. But it raises a really important question- do you REALLY know what's in your eliquid? Or is it all just.... heresay.
 

joemar4

Full Member
Nov 3, 2013
46
149
Long Island, NY
You know... This whole situation is just sad for everyone. People want to crucify the maker, which I understand- the guy made a BIG mistake using that ingredient, but I don't think he did it with any intention of malice. He used a food coloring that said on the bottle that it was safe for human consumption. So to the best of his limited knowledge, he was using a safe product. Also, the toxicology of Titanium Dioxide is much less than what we experienced as smokers.. not that this gives him a right to use it or hide the fact that he uses it... Just saying, its very unlikely that anyone will experience any adverse health effects from vaping this in the short term. This is not much different than the diacetyl argument, which many people are aware its in their juice and choose to vape it anyways.

However- It needs to be their choice. I would like to see the maker of Cuttwood publicly admit to his folly and try to make amends. Not addressing the accusation is only adding fuel to the fire. Clearly.

I feel bad for the people who bought this and feel betrayed because it wasn't disclosed. I feel bad for the vendors who are going to take a loss on this, although I do think they should have been more responsible and had the liquids they're selling have a GC/MS analysis done beforehand. Or require the maker to have one done. But since its an unregulated industry, none of this is a requirement. Still, its the right thing to do and could've totally avoided this problem.

I especially feel bad for the vaping community as a whole. Every vendor seems more suspect now, in light of this. But it raises a really important question- do you REALLY know what's in your eliquid? Or is it all just.... heresay.

Very, VERY, well put!! :thumb::thumb:
 

ruet

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 20, 2011
553
1,118
GR, MI
I especially feel bad for the vaping community as a whole. Every vendor seems more suspect now, in light of this. But it raises a really important question- do you REALLY know what's in your eliquid? Or is it all just.... heresay.

My main vendor ( who I shall not name in order to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest) is working with their suppliers to have all artificial colors removed from their flavorings. They are local as well so I can watch them, if I see fit, mix the liquid. Not all are so lucky though.
 
Wow. Have you even read what I posted?

It's a shame when a rumor can become truth with no evidence. If we allow this to happen to us we're no better than the FDA and lawmakers trying to ban ecigs.

I absolutely agree with you on the rumor part.

I didn't bite on the whole "cinnamon vapes are bad for you" thing a few months back. Why? Because the "research" came from a known anti-ecig organization. The "researchers" have been found to use improper methodology in the past. Cinnamon has been used in many forms for thousands of years without issue. Evaluate the facts at hand.

In this case we had two vendors (one of whom stated he was selling the product) make posts that the product was unsafe. One of the vendors even claimed to have spoken to the ejuice creator who confirmed the product ingredients and that he was unaware of the risks. Both of those posters comments were deleted and I believe the posters banned for the reason "unregistered forum supplier." So unless it is an ECF mod policy to ban everyone who claims to be a vendor you have just confirmed the identities of the people posting. Adding weight to their claims.

At/around the same time these comments were made here the manufacturer made a post that the formula of the product was being changed. Despite his claims that the ingredients were being changed "due to gunking up coils" I can't find a single ejuice vendor that has ever done this.

Said ejuice is cloudy when shaken, left alone most of the whiteness separates and settles in the bottom of the bottle in a particulate form. White food colorings frequently contain TiO2 which is safe for consumption as it is not absorbed by the stomach but it is not safe for inhalation.

The product is pulled from vendor shelves and people who ordered it online have their orders canceled. Refunds are offered, something not done during the cinnamon scare. Thousands of comments are made about the product's possible toxicity, the maker's Instagram page is also inundated yet not rebuttal is made. Not even a "we're looking into this" type post.

All of that adds up to some pretty heavy circumstantial evidence. We are at a crucial crossroads as vapers with the FDA and lawmakers. We need to police ourselves before some draconian measures are instituted against us.

Yes, it may turn out there is no TiO2 in the product and I will say it now: if there isn't I'm truly sorry for any disparaging comments I may have made and anyone I may have offended.
 
It really is. I read on the Instagram site one person actually said, "I feel very sorry for the juice maker because of all of this". or something to that effect. Yes....sorry for Jared. He's crying all the way to the bank. And the distributors have to initiate refunds. Where's this guy and why isn't he refunding anything. It's all very strange and at the same time, obvious. Your words ring true. The silence is deafening. Very well put.

If he truly didn't know that the substance was of concern then I feel sorry for the creator as well. Just imagine your whole business, source of income, go down the tubes because of a stupid mistake. Because one component out of several used to make your best selling product is safe in every form except inhalation and you didn't know that. Imagine losing everything over that? I think it would be awful.

Up until this morning I had put aside my "don't vape anything colored" personal rule and was trying to find a vendor to buy this from. It's the silence from the ejuice creator that bugs me the most. Well, that and the whole "we're reformulating because it was gunking up coils" thing that smacks of deception.
 

Sheila Michele 1971

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Here is my two cents:

First I would never vape something that looked like that so I have no horse in this race.
Second, this juice maker clearly has no PR experience and has not handled this controversy in a timely manner.
Thirdly, I doubt very seriously if the majority of those who feel screwed over will ever trust this vendor again. So yea, he might have made some money at the get go, but he wont have any real staying power.
Fourthly, Since the juicemaker is not sending anymore of these bottles out, it will make testing almost impossible unless those with UNSEALED juice bottles donate them for testing.

Lastly - For those wanting to send your juices somewhere to be tested......
If you want to send them to the MD lab on your dime, so be it.....

BUT

I would suggest contacting Dimitri from Vape TV and get this juice to Dr Farsalinos who is actually testing juices for safety. I believe VapersPlace is the website with their contact info or give them a call when they do their show.
 
I would suggest contacting Dimitri from Vape TV and get this juice to Dr Farsalinos who is actually testing juices for safety. I believe VapersPlace is the website with their contact info or give them a call when they do their show.

I like this ^

You could probably even get it done for free or whatever it costs to mail an unopened bottle to them.

I truly do feel bad for this juice manufacturer IF he didn't know the potential dangers of inhaled TiO2. As a nurse I know what kind of a difference a misplaced decimal point can make in a patient's health. If I ever have the faintest nagging that I don't know something about a medication I look it up. At my last job they referred to me as "good as Google" which I find an overstatement but flattering nonetheless because if I didn't know the answer to their question I would seek it out.

If this ejuice producer is vindicated I hope he becomes the next Mad Murdock, Grant's or (insert wildly successful ejuice maker here). I just hope he makes a statement to clear up the issue.
 

rolygate

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
8,354
12,405
ECF Towers
This thread became a war at one point, between two vendors who have no connection with ECF, who we know nothing about, who we can't recommend one way or the other, who chose to ignore our requests to stop, and after being banned for turning the place into a war zone then proceeded to create new identities and return to the fray.

As a result, the thread is being closed now. Everything that can be said has been said.

Our advice, as always, is to buy from known good vendors. The only possible way for us to speak on that subject is to suggest you deal with vendors registered here: because we know who they are and can enforce reasonable standards of customer care on them.

There are almost certainly good vendors who are not registered here, and there are hundreds - thousands probably - of bad ones who we ejected or who cannot register here as they don't comply with our minimum standards. If you wish to deal with non-ECF vendors then you must expect that some of them are cowboys. Not all - that is not what we are saying here - but some of them will be. If you deal with someone who is clearly a very small scale business, has no phone number on their website or it is not working, who has no known address, then it is a possibility they are a back-bedroom business and not in the best position to ensure your safety.

It's your decision to deal with them or not, but be aware: there is no cheap, good e-liquid. There is cheap e-liquid and there is good e-liquid. There is well-tested e-liquid and there is completely untested e-liquid that contains materials which no large business would put in because they are not willing to take the risks that a back-bedroom operator can. Your decision.

[edit]
It is unwise to add colorings of any kind to inhalable products (unless the colorings are proven safe for inhalation). Materials added to e-liquid to color it, or to color the vapor, are probably a bad idea. This is why when you choose a coffee flavor e-liquid, it may be a good idea to choose one with flavors designed for vaping, not for cakes. Food flavorings such as coffee flavor have dark coloring added in order to give a tan color to cake sponge. Inhalable coffee flavor is clear, with no coloring. You should probably avoid a dark color coffee e-liquid because the maker has used food flavoring that is obviously not designed for vaping, which is why these dark liquids can be problematic for the equipment and the lungs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ladiekali

rolygate

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
8,354
12,405
ECF Towers
Dr Farsalinos has offered this comment and we are glad to post it for him.


I would like to comment on this, without seeing or knowing who the vendor is and if the use of titanium dioxide has been verified or not.

First of all, titanium dioxide was probably used as a food coloring. It is really unfortunate that there are companies using food colorings in their products. These substances have NEVER been tested for inhalation, do not offer anything in terms of flavor or experience to the vaper and are only used for aesthetic purposes (if there is any real reason for making the liquid more colorful). Using something that has never been tested for inhalation purposes in order just to make the e-liquid 'look better' is AT LEAST an irresponsible behavior. Using food colorings introduces an unknown, potentially dangerous factor, for absolutely no reason. It does not promote the experience and pleasure perceived by consumers. For titanium dioxide, it is officially-classified as a probable carcinogen when inhaled.

You do not expect an e-cigarette vendor to be a scientist. No businessmen in other industries need to be scientists in order to own a business making a consumer product. However, in any other industry they are hiring experts (chemists etc.) to know what they are doing and what they are putting in the products. This has not been the case with e-cigarettes. So, instead of any vendor trying to be a scientist through the internet and Wikipedia, it is far better to avoid any 'experimentation' trying to make a 'novel', 'magic' recipe. Just stick with what is essential in an e-liquid (flavoring, solvents, nicotine). There is NO JUSTIFICATION like "I didn't know". You do not know and you cannot acquire the knowledge unless you are an expert or you hire an expert. Until you do that, any experimentation with new substances introduced to an e-liquid is unnecessary and dangerous.

Vapers should avoid such products.


Konstantinos Farsalinos, M.D.
Researcher, Onassis Cardiac Surgery Center, Athens Greece
Researcher, University Hospital Gathuisberg, Leuven, Belgium
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread