Putting the wire under too much tension anywhere in the coil set up can vary the resistance of the wire at that point. The "too tight" theory makes sense to me and is something that came to the surface with the AGA Ts because people were trying to pull the coil closer to the post thinking that it was the distance that was causing problems. Relieving some of that tension has seemed to work for some.
PS. I am now using a ceramic wick and it is brilliant. With these set up takes seconds and no shorts can occur. My juicy peach has never tasted cleaner or juicier, in fact, if the performance stays as good as it is now, I will never use a stainless wick again. Stainless just tastes funky to me now.