Vaping and losing weight

Status
Not open for further replies.

Miira

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 15, 2012
404
327
Seaside, CA
I am starting to lose weight but what I think it is, is the because PG and VG are humectants, I have been laying off of the cokes that I had a huge affinity for ( to the tune of 6 to 8 a day...I know...I know lol) and have been drinking a lot more water.

The same happened to me, but with Mt. Dew. I didn't intentionally quit drinking soda, it just happened.
 

Kioso

Full Member
Jun 1, 2012
7
0
36
US
This time last year I was smoking a pack a day. I decided to start getting it better shape so I started jogging 5 miles everyday (while on analogs!) It was ROUGH but after about 2 weeks I was actually doing it daily. I dropped a pant size in 3 months then the weight loss just stopped. So, I started dieting, actually went vegetarian for awhile there. Lots of raw fruits and veggies and nuts/hummus once a week. Dropped a pound or two over the next 2 months. Then was at a stand still.

Then I found e-cigs. I stopped smoking and started vaping! The 5 miles I usually run daily became nothing after just 2 weeks. So, I started going further! I found myself eating two meals a day (a medium and a small) with a smoothie before bed time. I think the tasty vapor helped me with cravings, honestly! My 34's are now too loose and I need to wear a belt! Crap, thought I was suppose to be saving money by vaping, now I found myself having to spend $$$ on new clothes (kidding of course!)
 

Blinx

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2012
104
25
38
Springdale, Arkansas
Since I've quit smoking I feel more motivated to improve my life in other ways.If I can quit smoking(something I thought I could never do before) then I can loose weight no problem. Exercising and dieting seems like a much easier goal to accomplish. Lost 10 pounds so far but have plans to really kick my exercise up in the next couple weeks.
 

CHoKPoP

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2012
106
14
usa
I'm not sure how useful this post will be, because I will be discussing something outside of conventional wisdom. Humans tend to gain weight because of insulin insensitivity. Exercise isn't a very effective way to lose weight over the long term, because it is unsustainable to keep up with the amount of exercise required to burn excess fat stores.

The fact that insulin is pretty much the sole regulator of fat accumulation of our bodies is well known. If you want to lose weight, try cutting carbohydrate intake.
 

Kioso

Full Member
Jun 1, 2012
7
0
36
US
I'm not sure how useful this post will be, because I will be discussing something outside of conventional wisdom. Humans tend to gain weight because of insulin insensitivity. Exercise isn't a very effective way to lose weight over the long term, because it is unsustainable to keep up with the amount of exercise required to burn excess fat stores.

The fact that insulin is pretty much the sole regulator of fat accumulation of our bodies is well known. If you want to lose weight, try cutting carbohydrate intake.


Very informative post, ChoKPoP. It's probably note worthy to mention that exercise is still very good for you.. I can't speak for everyone here obviously, but for me personally since I got off analogs it's been about a healthier way of life. Everything after that are just the benefits of that choice.
 

Flurfel

Full Member
Verified Member
May 26, 2012
40
126
Birmingham,, AL
I'm not sure how useful this post will be, because I will be discussing something outside of conventional wisdom. Humans tend to gain weight because of insulin insensitivity. Exercise isn't a very effective way to lose weight over the long term, because it is unsustainable to keep up with the amount of exercise required to burn excess fat stores.

The fact that insulin is pretty much the sole regulator of fat accumulation of our bodies is well known. If you want to lose weight, try cutting carbohydrate intake.

Carbs are a good place to cut, but carbs are also a good source of energy too. The bottom line is if you take in less calories than you burn, you lose weight.
 

CHoKPoP

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2012
106
14
usa
Carbs are a good place to cut, but carbs are also a good source of energy too. The bottom line is if you take in less calories than you burn, you lose weight.
This unfortunately is the conventional wisdom, and is completely untrue. Carbs are NOT an essential part of the human diet. If you remove carbs completely from your diet, you are now on a ketogenic diet. We synthesize glucagon from our pancreas to replace glucose. A calorie is not a calorie. Our bodies aren't as simple as subtracting calories in vs calories burned. Did you not read when I said that weight accumulation is based on a hormonal inbalance? My main point I want to address is that if you tend to gain weight, you must cut carbs. If you get to a point when you've cut enough so you reach a stable hormonal balance, you can slowly incorporate carbs in your diet. Some carbs are more damaging than others. Sugar obviously is the worst offender, and I would advise anyone to cut that out first.
 

CHoKPoP

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2012
106
14
usa
Very informative post, ChoKPoP. It's probably note worthy to mention that exercise is still very good for you.. I can't speak for everyone here obviously, but for me personally since I got off analogs it's been about a healthier way of life. Everything after that are just the benefits of that choice.
I will agree with you that exercise does have some health benefits, but I feel as though long term weight loss isn't one of those.
 

Vapoor eyes er

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Sep 13, 2011
11,028
8,945
Toronto, Ont.
Yep agree completely. Carbs are a serious no- no. Sugar...the sugar cartel are no better than BT IMO and if people researched they be absolutely shocked. Here's a vid that explains the Sugar Cartel.
rangiwicked (vodpod)'s Decalz: CBC.Big.Sugar.1of2.Xvid.mp3.avi | Lockerz
As stated I exercise because I enjoy the sports I participate in and if my overall physical health improves it's a HUGE bonus. Add to that the notable improvement in my mental/ psychological state and it's a win- win. As for looking slim and fit I'll take it but it's really down at the bottom of my list of benefits of exercising.

This unfortunately is the conventional wisdom, and is completely untrue. Carbs are NOT an essential part of the human diet. If you remove carbs completely from your diet, you are now on a ketogenic diet. We synthesize glucagon from our pancreas to replace glucose. A calorie is not a calorie. Our bodies aren't as simple as subtracting calories in vs calories burned. Did you not read when I said that weight accumulation is based on a hormonal inbalance? My main point I want to address is that if you tend to gain weight, you must cut carbs. If you get to a point when you've cut enough so you reach a stable hormonal balance, you can slowly incorporate carbs in your diet. Some carbs are more damaging than others. Sugar obviously is the worst offender, and I would advise anyone to cut that out first.
 

Flurfel

Full Member
Verified Member
May 26, 2012
40
126
Birmingham,, AL
This unfortunately is the conventional wisdom, and is completely untrue. Carbs are NOT an essential part of the human diet. If you remove carbs completely from your diet, you are now on a ketogenic diet. We synthesize glucagon from our pancreas to replace glucose. A calorie is not a calorie. Our bodies aren't as simple as subtracting calories in vs calories burned. Did you not read when I said that weight accumulation is based on a hormonal inbalance? My main point I want to address is that if you tend to gain weight, you must cut carbs. If you get to a point when you've cut enough so you reach a stable hormonal balance, you can slowly incorporate carbs in your diet. Some carbs are more damaging than others. Sugar obviously is the worst offender, and I would advise anyone to cut that out first.

Well, we'll just have to agree to disagree on this. I'll have to take my personal experience, which is 30+ years as an athlete(Soccer and Rugby) and U.S. Army 11BC2. Absolutely some carbs are worse offenders than other, those cokes were horrible for me, whereas the spaghetti dinners the night before a big match were very beneficial. I did read where you said that weight accumulation is based on hormonal imbalance. This is true, but not the only truth. The analogy I'll use here is to say that cancer is caused by smoking. Is this a cause of some instances of cancer? Absolutely. Do people that have never smoked or been around second hand smoke get cancer? Absolutely. The same thing is true about hormonal imbalance and weight gain. This is the difference between inductive and deductive reasoning.

Hormonal Balance + [Calories Taken In –( Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss

Hormonal Imbalance + [Less Calories Taken In –( Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss

Hormonal Imbalance + [Calories Taken In –(More Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss
 

yzer

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Nov 23, 2011
5,248
3,870
Northern California
My last cigarettes was over two months ago. I've gained five pounds. Five pounds may not sound like a lot but this time of year I usually drop five pounds due to summer activity. I'm getting more exercise, eating less, and eating more fresh fruits and vegetables. I'll continue the diet and exercise trend until I start to lose some weight again.

The major issue for me has been an increase in snacking. There was something about tobacco smoke that controlled my appetite to a greater extent than vaping nicotine.
 

CHoKPoP

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 6, 2012
106
14
usa
Well, we'll just have to agree to disagree on this. I'll have to take my personal experience, which is 30+ years as an athlete(Soccer and Rugby) and U.S. Army 11BC2. Absolutely some carbs are worse offenders than other, those cokes were horrible for me, whereas the spaghetti dinners the night before a big match were very beneficial. I did read where you said that weight accumulation is based on hormonal imbalance. This is true, but not the only truth. The analogy I'll use here is to say that cancer is caused by smoking. Is this a cause of some instances of cancer? Absolutely. Do people that have never smoked or been around second hand smoke get cancer? Absolutely. The same thing is true about hormonal imbalance and weight gain. This is the difference between inductive and deductive reasoning. Hormonal Balance + [Calories Taken In –( Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss Hormonal Imbalance + [Less Calories Taken In –( Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss Hormonal Imbalance + [Calories Taken In –(More Calories Burned >Calories Taken In)] = Lasting Fat Loss
Alright, so you are relying purely on anecdotal evidence, and conventional wisdom. I will stay on the side of science. You eat 2000 calories of chocolate cake. You eat 2000 pounds of meat. Your body will not respond the same in both scenarios. You admitted yourself that some carbs are worse than others. A calorie is not a calorie. They have nothing to do with the regulation of fat stores. When I spoke of a Hormonal Imbalance, I was talking about INSULIN. If you have more insulin in your body, you will store more fat. Insulin's job is to store fat in the body. Animals in nature have no idea about how many calories they eat. They have no belt that feels tight, yet under your hypothesis they still manage to match calories in with calories out. This makes no sense. It's time to educate people why obesity is such an epidemic in our society. We give bad advice, eat less exercise more. Clearly it has not been working. Why don't you read something by Gary Taubes? It will blow your mind.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread