As others have stated, I don't think that you'll find one that tastes like a cigarette, but I also think you'll find something that you like. You'll also find that taste is very subjective no matter what flavors you try.
I smoked Marlboro Reds years ago, switched to Mediums for a while and smoked Marlboro Lights for the past 15 years probably. I read in here how you won't find one that tastes like a cig, but I still expected the
juice to taste like a cig for some reason. My first
juice was USA Mix 18 mg. It took me a while to figure out what the taste reminded me off, but I eventually settled on molasses. If you've ever had
real molasses, that's what I thought it tasted most like. You're right though, it tastes much more like a pipe or cigar tobacco than a cigarette.
I have a bunch of LorAnn flavorings and haven't tried them all yet, but I've found that I like tobacco flavored
juice much better than the flavors that I've tried so far. Bubble gum was ok for a while, but I grew tired of it. Pralines & Cream was not quite as good, but I could handle it on occasion. I tried other flavors like Pepsi, remarkably it tasted like a fountain pop and was ok as well. A lot of people seem to like 555, but personally I hate it. We're all different... Camel, to me, tasted too much like cotton candy. I have Virginia, DK Tab and Hilton on order, I'll let you know what I think on those. My current fave and the one I keep going back to is MyBoro 24 mg Liberty Liquid from MyPVshop.com. I cut it with about 25-30% glycerin and I vape it all day long. It works well for me, but may not for others.
If you stick with it, you'll find what works for you. If you do find that one juice that tastes like a freshly fired up Marlboro Light, please let me know.