What's yours ? Mesh cotton?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gill gee

New Member
Nov 11, 2014
2
0
Scotland
Hi guys, on my vape journey I've tried allsorts of cotton and silica ,I've not yet tried mesh , I've used normal cotton, even cotton yarn I find awesome , at the moment I'm using (natura crochet yarn :) ) it's combed cotton and I stumbled on it by accident , it doesn't need any breaking in its full on flavour from that first puff,when I use regular non organic cotton,even after 3 boils I get a funky taste .ive heard cotton needs broke in ? True ? I don't know to be honest ,I'm getting some organic just to ease my mind lol, what's your wicking materials? I'm using in my kayfun and Russian [ dmc natura cotton yarn] it's by far the best flavour I've had outta all the cotton yarn etc I e tried ,only £3 for a massive ball that'll last forever ,I really want to use cotton wool though ,but that funky taste puts me right off
 

Susan~S

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 12, 2014
16,936
11,694
69
Mpls/St.Paul, MN
I prefer Japanese cotton pads -- Ko Gen Do or Shiseido but have used Cellucotton Rayon as well.

Here are some links:

1. Cellucotton (Rayon) - at Sally's Beauty Supply ($11.49 for 500 feet)
2. Shiseido - at Sephora ($9.50) or Macy's or Nordstroms
3. Ko Gen Do - at Sephora ($12.00 for 60 pads)

Graham Cellucotton Box Numbers: 44060 (500 ft), 44043 (3 lbs = 900 ft), 44040 (1200 ft), 44130 (40 ft).
 

Dampmaskin

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 28, 2014
1,042
1,157
Norway
www.steam-engine.org
I mostly use Japanese cotton. Sometimes 2.5 mm quality silica. Once in a while #500 SS mesh.

I find that cotton gives the vape a certain clothy taste, but it's not unpleasant. No break-in needed, at least for the cotton I use.

SS mesh gives me the stingy metallic taste of hot legs (or rather hot spots), or the taste of burnt juice, if I don't build it right. When it's done right, and not gunked up, the taste is clean.

Silica hos no taste that I can discern.
 

reverser

Full Member
Verified Member
Dec 6, 2011
42
24
東京
It's definitely a hassle to work with at first, but if you're up to the challenge, in my experience an SS mesh wick provides excellent flavor, quick flavor swaps, and unparalleled longevity.

I don't have direct experience with your setup(s), but from a quick Google search, it looks as though others have done full ss mesh wicks on both of your atomizers. You will get varying information from different folks that have had different experiences, but I prefer NOT to pre-oxidize the wick as it leaves a charred black substance (carbon?) all over the mesh that distorts the taste (my opinion) and reduces the life of the mesh (fact). The wick will slowly oxidize itself (and work out the shorts) as you begin to heat the coil for the first time (prime with plain VG / PG as you perform this "burn-in").

With that said, you will most certainly start with shorts that need to be worked out, and this the hassle I refer to in the beginning of the post. The trick is to pre-roll the coil on a drill bit, small screwdriver, etc., then install it into the RBA with just enough space that the rolled mesh wick can be slid in and make light contact. Shorts can be poked and prodded out using a dental tool. Additionally, rolling the mesh on the diagonal will allow the mesh to bend to fit into your atomizer without kinks. It's definitely something that requires a bit of patience and practice.

With a dry burn after every 5-10 fills, you basically start with a "fresh" atomizer. The more you dry burn, the quicker the mesh will deteriorate in the area around the coil, so there's a balance game that you will become familiar with as you use this type of setup more.

It's worth a try at least. It's my experience that many of the current vapers have been introduced to the "cloud chasing" style of vaping and have sub-ohm dual coil setups with Japanese organic cotton running at far too high a wattage to actually taste the juice. I've given that approach a fair shot, but find a traditional single coil setup between 1-1.5 ohms with SS mesh provides a far better flavor and long term vaping experience.

YMMV
 
Last edited:

Dana A

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 25, 2012
2,778
1,292
48
Iowa
It's definitely a hassle to work with at first, but if you're up to the challenge, in my experience an SS mesh wick provides excellent flavor, quick flavor swaps, and unparalleled longevity.

I don't have direct experience with your setup(s), but from a quick Google search, it looks as though others have done full ss mesh wicks on both of your atomizers. You will get varying information from different folks that have had different experiences, but I prefer NOT to pre-oxidize the wick as it leaves a charred black substance (carbon?) all over the mesh that distorts the taste (my opinion) and reduces the life of the mesh (fact). The wick will slowly oxidize itself (and work out the shorts) as you begin to heat the coil for the first time (prime with plain VG / PG as you perform this "burn-in").

With that said, you will most certainly start with shorts that need to be worked out, and this the hassle I refer to in the beginning of the post. The trick is to pre-roll the coil on a drill bit, small screwdriver, etc., then install it into the RBA with just enough space that the rolled mesh wick can be slid in and make light contact. Shorts can be poked and prodded out using a dental tool. Additionally, rolling the mesh on the diagonal will allow the mesh to bend to fit into your atomizer without kinks. It's definitely something that requires a bit of patience and practice.

With a dry burn after every 5-10 fills, you basically start with a "fresh" atomizer. The more you dry burn, the quicker the mesh will deteriorate in the area around the coil, so there's a balance game that you will become familiar with as you use this type of setup more.

It's worth a try at least. It's my experience that many of the current vapers have been introduced to the "cloud chasing" style of vaping and have sub-ohm dual coil setups with Japanese organic cotton running at far too high a wattage to actually taste the juice. I've given that approach a fair shot, but find a traditional single coil setup between 1-1.5 ohms with SS mesh provides a far better flavor and long term vaping experience.

YMMV

^^^^^This exactly^^^^^

The SS mesh wicks last me about 8 months. That's with a dry burn after every single tank because I use dark sweet liquids. I scrape the coil after dry burning with a dental pick and the whole thing is like brand new. Each wire coil lasts me about 2 or 3 weeks. So simple and fail proof once you get it down. I do torch the heck out of my wicks when I 1st make them though.
 

Kaezziel

Supreme Overlord of Everything
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 29, 2014
4,536
47,824
Houston, TX, USA
I run rayon in everything.... It's in my drippers, my Orchid, and my genny tanks... I've gotten through about 105ml or so on the wicks in my Orchid without a change... I can get 2 weeks out of my drippers before I change the coils out of boredom... I don't use my genny a whole lot, but those wicks have been in there for about 2 months and still work like they did the day I put 'em in... I've pretty much completely given up on all other wick materials...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread