Where's j0ker?????

Status
Not open for further replies.

zelda

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 21, 2009
7,433
11,278
Echo Beach
Just don't forget to do some walking over Jerry. :lol:

Oh I never forget!!!:laugh: But here in Mass I'd probably get in big trouble for stepping on a bird.
That's why I stuck with a rock. :facepalm::laugh:
npjibc.jpg


I'm heading back over the pond. :p :lol:

As if those genteel British women
2e5plrp.jpg


are more fun than us lusty American women.
americangirl.gif
2b2kaq.jpg
;)
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
I didn't want Huddy (House & Cuddy hookup) but when it happened it had great potential. And they blew it -- turned Cuddy into a shrew and House into a cowardly baby. So last year was very hit & miss for me. But this year is a return to the basics. It reminds me of the first three seasons and I'm loving it.

I agree they blew Huddy but we disagree on what's happened since. Bringing in the first kid - a terrible 'facial expression'-sit com-type actress (and from what I gather from a form of 'nepotism') and now Park :facepalm: who probably couldn't make it on Big Bang. I don't see 'basics' at all. House has become a eunuch. A smart one.... perhaps. Chase as a TV doctor?? Brilliant! :facepalm: The writers have done the same thing with House that the writers of NYPD did with Sippowitz - killed the golden goose. But they tend to do that after a long run... they run out of ideas. I don't know the 'internals' but my guess is that some writers left a while back.
 

Poeia

Bird Brain
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 6, 2009
9,789
14,368
NYC
Most of the writers are still there but we lost Doris Egan. MAJOR loss. She was the most interested in the House/Wilson dynamic and wrote some great episodes including:
Failure to Communicate - when House & Stacy were in Baltimore and Michael O'Keefe couldn't talk
House vs. God - the faith healer kid. Probably still my favorite episode
Son of a Coma Guy - with John Larroquette in Atlantic City
Birthmarks - House and Wilson go to John House's funeral
The Social Contract - The patient who can't stop himself from saying every thought that comes into his head. And Wilson's brother is found
Both Sides Now - final episode for S5 - House goes crazy and checks into Mayfield
and the story for House's Head (the bus accident) was her idea.

I don't agree that House has jumped the shark but that might be a question of definition. To me that's when a show runs out of ideas and starts doing stunts to pull in viewers. Fonzie literally jumped a shark on Happy Days. On My Three Sons, Robbie got married and ratings went up (1966). After a couple of years, they started dropping again so Steve got married (1969). The next year, Chip got married during his first year in college. The triplets were the year after that. If the show hadn't ended, Ernie would probably gotten married while he was still in high school.

I agree that House is not as consistently good brilliant as it was in the first few years. And there have been some stupid episodes. But, beyond the extreme willing suspension of disbelief necessary when watching TV (a doctor who is allowed to treat one patient a week; Tritter being allowed to roam the hospital and read patient files at will; Foreman having the choice of whether House goes back to jail if he goes where he's not allowed…) I haven't seen things I can't fanw@nk myself into believing.

Odette Annabel is the result of nepotism? What did you hear? This is her 4th or 5th TV series. I think the character is kind of lame but that's not her fault.
Charlyne Yi is hysterically funny and it's a great character but she can't act -- as she would be the first to say. She's a stand-up comic. They came to her.


ETA: And by "back to basics" I mean that House is obsessed with the medical problems again.

I agree they blew Huddy but we disagree on what's happened since. Bringing in the first kid - a terrible 'facial expression'-sit com-type actress (and from what I gather from a form of 'nepotism') and now Park :facepalm: who probably couldn't make it on Big Bang. I don't see 'basics' at all. House has become a eunuch. A smart one.... perhaps. Chase as a TV doctor?? Brilliant! :facepalm: The writers have done the same thing with House that the writers of NYPD did with Sippowitz - killed the golden goose. But they tend to do that after a long run... they run out of ideas. I don't know the 'internals' but my guess is that some writers left a while back.
 
Last edited:

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
Poe:Most of the writers are still there but we lost Doris Egan. MAJOR loss. She was the most interested in the House/Wilson dynamic and wrote some great episodes including:

Yep, good writer. Although she perhaps should have intervened on "Meaning"(2006) episode. That should have been a House/Wilson dynamic killer.

I don't agree that House has jumped the shark but that might be a question of definition.

Yeah, 'jumped the shark' really doesn't fit - I'd go with 'neutered' the shark :laugh:

I agree that House is not as consistently good brilliant as it was in the first few years.

I'd go further than that - season 6.

And there have been some stupid episodes. But, beyond the extreme willing suspension of disbelief...

I get that but I'm talking overall for the last two seasons with only a few exceptions.

Odette Annabel is the result of nepotism? What did you hear?

Sorry, I meant Amber Tamblyn of season 7. And my mistake on nepotism - I just checked and I must have misinterpretted a story on her and her husband... I agree, Odette's character is lame...so far anyway. Never considered her a kid. :) I could have been clearer, I guess - but I meant Masters and Park.

Charlyne Yi is hysterically funny and it's a great character but she can't act -- as she would be the first to say. She's a stand-up comic. They came to her.

Wrong move, imo. And it's turned the show into one big facepalm, (think Big Bang and you'll be close) - well that and other stuff as well.

ETA: And by "back to basics" I mean that House is obsessed with the medical problems again.

Actually, that, imo, never left - what changed is the storyline from Season 7 and the results. I actually don't think that his character would react the way they've written it. He was much more able than that. But I think they/writers and likely the directors and producers want to show some karma or something (typical, without getting into the politics) - a concept his character would never acknowledge or dramatize.
 

Poeia

Bird Brain
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 6, 2009
9,789
14,368
NYC
I think Amber Tamblyn is a wonderful actress. (I'm tempted to watch Joan of Arcadia because of her -- haven't yet, but I ight.)I hated Masters when she started but she became almost tolerable to me. The character was created because they had fired Jennifer Morrison and gave Olivia Wilde most of the season off to become a movie star so they needed a female member of the team to fill in the gap.

The nepotism you speak of is that she and Katie Jacobs are developing a future series together. But you've got it backwards. She agreed to do the show as a favor. She signed up for 14 episodes. They wanted her to stay on after OW came back but she wasn't interested.

ETA: Re Doris Egan, if she worked on Meaning she wouldn't have had time to finish Son of a Coma Guy. Meaning was written by David Shore (you know him), Lawrence Kaplow and the team of Russel Friend & Garrett Lerner. Love Kaplow (e.g. Detox; Kids; The Honeymoon; Autopsy; Who's Your Daddy; Half-Wit; Under My Skin), indifferent to Friend/Lerner (Euphoria (part 2); Fetal Position; 97 Seconds; Let Them Eat Cake) but they did do Broken (the 2 hour episode at Mayfield.)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread