You should give
Beatle Juice (Marbrow) ECigarette Refill with WTA a try... very satisfying and tastes almost exactly like an unlit red. It has an ashy taste on the very first puff, and then that's gone. What remains is a sour tobacco taste that shouldn't taste good, but is surprisingly perfect. It's full bodied, but doesn't have much flavor, vapor production and throat hit are almost exactly like a real analog.
FYI, this is a WTA blend, so it uses an alkaloid extract only from tobacco. WTA's are for vapers who are noticing something missing from their vape. It gives a nice relaxing buzz similar to what you get from analogs. I love it, and even with WTA, it's still like 98% safer than smoking an analog.