Who has the best Menthol
- Thread starter Rockproof
- Start date
- th_trl_thread_readers 0
-
- Tags
- halo madvapes vapor room
- Status
Menthol is cheap and easy to make. Some suppliers add mint to their menthol liquids. If you like that, it is not a problem. Are you interested in DIY or prepared liquid? You can buy menthol crystals for about $1 and dissolve them and they will last years.
I really like Backwoods Brew's Tobacco Menthol. You can order it with light, medium, or strong menthol.
Cignot's Methol is not bad either. In fact that was the first juice I ever vaped.
Cignot's Methol is not bad either. In fact that was the first juice I ever vaped.
Last edited:
Vapor renu tobacco menthol such as honeywood menthol, 555 menthol, east coast menthol(like a newport), west coast menthol, fired cured menthol, havana menthol, maple rum menthol, Re4 nu menthol all all good. If I had to rate these...
Honeywood
East Coast
Re4 nu
havana menthol
555 menthol
Fired cure menthol
Maple rum is new for me so it has not made it to the list...just trying it today.
West coast is my least favorite..different but lowest on my list.
You can also buy the flavoring or buy some from flavorwest.
They do sell bulk juice.
I find the juice better than the vendors I ordered from thus far...won't name the vendors...I am finding the bigger name vendors on this forum all taste alike..nothing special. This is my view only.
Honeywood
East Coast
Re4 nu
havana menthol
555 menthol
Fired cure menthol
Maple rum is new for me so it has not made it to the list...just trying it today.
West coast is my least favorite..different but lowest on my list.
You can also buy the flavoring or buy some from flavorwest.
They do sell bulk juice.
I find the juice better than the vendors I ordered from thus far...won't name the vendors...I am finding the bigger name vendors on this forum all taste alike..nothing special. This is my view only.
Last edited:
Vapor Renu honey wood menthol is fantastic. I also got a bottle of re(4)nu menthol which is essentially unusable. Smells and tastes very medicinal, very different menthol from the bottle of honey wood I ordered at the same time. No idea why.
Sounds like I'm going to have to try Silver Leaf. But, the best I've found, closest to analog is freedomsmokeusa's Pall Mall. Select extra flavor and ask them to add menthol. That's my all day vape now.
But, FSUSA's American Spirit Menthol and New/Port are very good. They're Wyatt Earp Menthol is pretty good but it has a unique flavor to it. I'm not real big on it, but I do enjoy it when I need a change.
Also, these I haven't used long term yet, so I'm not totally sold yet, but I do like them.
Backwoods Brew Tobacco menthol
Vaporbomb, Shade Menthol, Max Ultimate and Virginia Menthol
Tasty Vapor Tobacco Menthol
I'm specifically a menthol (or straight tobacco every once in a while) vaper. And I am very picky and have tried many kinds. As with all flavors, it is subjective, but with menthol, I think it's even more. Depends on whether you want more menthol, more minty, a lot of tobacco, little or no tobacco. I've tried many, many menthols thinking I was looking for MORE menthol. Now that I'm settled down and off of analogs, I'm finding that I like more of a tobacco flavor with less menthol. Thanks why my favorite is Pall Mall with menthol.
Good luck!
But, FSUSA's American Spirit Menthol and New/Port are very good. They're Wyatt Earp Menthol is pretty good but it has a unique flavor to it. I'm not real big on it, but I do enjoy it when I need a change.
Also, these I haven't used long term yet, so I'm not totally sold yet, but I do like them.
Backwoods Brew Tobacco menthol
Vaporbomb, Shade Menthol, Max Ultimate and Virginia Menthol
Tasty Vapor Tobacco Menthol
I'm specifically a menthol (or straight tobacco every once in a while) vaper. And I am very picky and have tried many kinds. As with all flavors, it is subjective, but with menthol, I think it's even more. Depends on whether you want more menthol, more minty, a lot of tobacco, little or no tobacco. I've tried many, many menthols thinking I was looking for MORE menthol. Now that I'm settled down and off of analogs, I'm finding that I like more of a tobacco flavor with less menthol. Thanks why my favorite is Pall Mall with menthol.
Good luck!
On youtube there are videos with simple instructions for melting a few menthol crystals into vg creating menthol flavoring for ejuice. You just warm it up to melt it. I just bought crystals from OSDIYS for $1.25 and I bought PA menthol liquid flavoring for $1.50. You only need a few drops because menthol is so strong. They sell the nic liquid as well and other flavors. I buy my VG from Walmart, $3. It's in the first aid section by the pharmacy.
I have been told by more than a few menthol smokers that the tobacco/menthol juice that I mix is very good. It's simple too. For flavoring I use 8 parts Tobacco Blend in PG from Perfumers Apprentice to 1 part Menthol Liquid also from PA. The menthol liquid is just crystals dissolved in food grade alcohol for easier mixing.
Thanks again all. Now I will begin my journy down "the best menthol route". Definitely going to try the Silver Leaf but also would like to try DIY with crystals. The idea of adding the amount of menth I like is appealing.
Good luck Rock. If you go the DIY route consider the menthol liquid from Perfumers Apprentice. It's really just the crystals dissolved in alcohol. It's easier to measure and control. GO LIGHT WITH MENTHOL! That stuff is STRONG!
I agree about the menthol crystals. I LOVE menthol and just melt a little bit and a couple drops and it's good to go. If you like a strong tobacco taste with menthol, The Vapor Room's 555Menthol was my go to juice when I first quit the analogs. I just got some Honey Wood Menthol from Vapor Renu and I can't stop vaping it. Also like Gourmet Vapor's A Tasty Menthol Ciggarette (that's how they spell it) and Freedom Smokes Virginia Menthol. Good luck!
I personally don't care for menthol flavors. It's probably because of years ago when I tried menthol analogs, I kept getting a sore throat; however, if I had to direct you to the best place for the best menthol flavoring, it would have to be My Freedom Smokes. The reason for sending you to MFS is because I haven't run across a flavor they have that I didn't like.
MFS is THE place where I get my e-liquids. They have all kinds of flavors and if there is a special combination you wish to try, all you need to do is contact Chris, the owner with your needs and he will do whatever it takes to match a flavor you'll like.
A short time ago I wanted to see if he could mix a bottle that would match the Sweet Dreams' Cherry Flavored analogs. With the exception of needing just a smidge more cherry in the tobacco liquid and it would be perfect. I had (still have a little) cherry flavored e-liquid so I added just a touch more and it was perfect.
BTW, he also has menthol crystals in the DIY area so if you want more menthol flavor, you can order the menthol crystals, melt them then add a drop or two at a time until reaching the exact menthol flavor should you need a bit more menthol or if you find a tobacco flavor you want to add menthol to, the crystals are there to make the change from standard flavored tobacco to a menthol flavored tobacco e-liquid.
Hope this helps.
Paise
MFS is THE place where I get my e-liquids. They have all kinds of flavors and if there is a special combination you wish to try, all you need to do is contact Chris, the owner with your needs and he will do whatever it takes to match a flavor you'll like.
A short time ago I wanted to see if he could mix a bottle that would match the Sweet Dreams' Cherry Flavored analogs. With the exception of needing just a smidge more cherry in the tobacco liquid and it would be perfect. I had (still have a little) cherry flavored e-liquid so I added just a touch more and it was perfect.
BTW, he also has menthol crystals in the DIY area so if you want more menthol flavor, you can order the menthol crystals, melt them then add a drop or two at a time until reaching the exact menthol flavor should you need a bit more menthol or if you find a tobacco flavor you want to add menthol to, the crystals are there to make the change from standard flavored tobacco to a menthol flavored tobacco e-liquid.
Hope this helps.
Paise
My favorite is the Menthol Ultra from FreedomsmokeUSA. It not spearmint or Wintergreen. It's straight menthol. I just got a bottle with a doubleshot of the menthol flavoring. It's like lighting up a Hall's cough drop. I like it a lot.
I was a menthol smoker for 42 years, 30 years on the same brand. In the time that I've been vaping I've also tried umpteen menthols looking for the elusive 'one'. But in that time my tastes have changed somewhat I have found. I now find I don't like tobacco taste in my vapes - at all. In fact the smell turns me right off, so much I thought that some of my juices had gone bad. Anyone else had that affect?
Anyhow, what I'm vaping now and it has become my very first 'all day every day' vape is VaporBomb's Arctic Ice. It really is quite strong, which again for me is unusual but the flavour and the sheer throat and lung freeze on a full drag is amazing. But if I take a mouth drag and not a direct to the lungs drag it isn't quite as 'brutish'. Just real tasty. That's on my eGo which is 3.2v and 2.8 to 3.0 ohm CE2's. If I put it on my VGO which is 3.7v it really is too strong for me, but I do do it occasionally for the fun of it.
I just bought some 'Chill Factor' additive but I haven't found out how to use it yet. Anyone tried it out?
Anyhow, what I'm vaping now and it has become my very first 'all day every day' vape is VaporBomb's Arctic Ice. It really is quite strong, which again for me is unusual but the flavour and the sheer throat and lung freeze on a full drag is amazing. But if I take a mouth drag and not a direct to the lungs drag it isn't quite as 'brutish'. Just real tasty. That's on my eGo which is 3.2v and 2.8 to 3.0 ohm CE2's. If I put it on my VGO which is 3.7v it really is too strong for me, but I do do it occasionally for the fun of it.
I just bought some 'Chill Factor' additive but I haven't found out how to use it yet. Anyone tried it out?
I just got my order from Alien Visions, which included two bottles of menthol drops. 4-8 drops per 10ml of juice and instantly any juice you have is menthol. This may be the best money I've spent yet!!
- Status
Similar threads
