I've come full circle on tobacco flavors since I started vaping, it's what i looked for initially and I tried some really bad ones. Then I moved away from these to mints, fruits, a few bakery and gourmet flavors. Last month I discovered the wonderful world of NEts, naturally extracted tobaccos which mostly are really more like pipe tobacco than cigarettes, but a deep, rich, and complex flavor. HHV has some wonderful ones I must say, legend, serendipity, Shadow, and Darkhorse are the ones I've enjoyed most. Darkhorse is the one a little more like cig tobacco IMO, less of the pipe but still very, very good. If you're looking for cigarette like tobaccos, I'd start with this one. I also am a fan of Vermillion River Premium Kentucky NET, and Halo TriBeCa, as well as several vendors that offer flue cured. I'd recommend these as well to you if that, as much of a cigarette flavor as you are likely to find without burning tobacco and paper, is what you are looking for.
Mountain Oak Vapor has a Gold Tennesee tobacco line many enjoy as well, but the only one I've liked from theirs so far is Sunday Morning. Again though, a title more of a pipe or cigar tobacco, IMO.