hey sally - i've tried the peppermint ice cream in the carts and they were very good.. nice sweet peppermint with a little cream... i really enjoyed it....now there is a difference in the reg. peppermint carts, it does have a stronger mint flavour to it, but i don't think you would be disappointed in the ice cream version... but of course this is only my opinion of the flavour. has anyone tried out the peppermint ice cream juice? i would buy some if it tasted like the carts... one more thing i think they only have pepp ice cream in the premiums...